FAangband 0.3.6

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Psi
    replied
    Originally posted by PowerDiver
    I decided to give the comp a try. Where can I find spoilers on what effects the various cure potions remove, what percentage resist is necessary to avoid side effects of breath weapons, what food items like "cake of beornings" do, etc?
    I'm not sure if such spoilers exist. I thought the potions were standard (apart from the new V percentage healing).

    You need 20% min for breath effects except poison which is 80% IIRC.

    Elvish bread and cakes of the Beornings heal a few HP other than that I really have no idea. Sprigs of Athelas heal the black breath.
    Originally posted by PowerDiver
    Also, the Ent has a '-' under intrinsic FF. Does that mean it takes one source of FF to break even and 2 would give FF effect? Or does that mean FF is always ignored?
    Ents can never get feather falling.

    Leave a comment:


  • PowerDiver
    replied
    I decided to give the comp a try. Where can I find spoilers on what effects the various cure potions remove, what percentage resist is necessary to avoid side effects of breath weapons, what food items like "cake of beornings" do, etc?

    Also, the Ent has a '-' under intrinsic FF. Does that mean it takes one source of FF to break even and 2 would give FF effect? Or does that mean FF is always ignored?

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    "Resistance to life draining" - how does it work?
    Got it from my Angband weapon, and the "C"haracter screen simply notes "Hlife +" .. does it mean this is supposed to work 100% like free action, see invisible etc.?
    Up to now, those "W" and "V" weren't able to drain me, but a skeletons serpents spit attack seemingly did 329 XP "damage" .. it's listed as 10d6+, so it looks like it did full damage ?!
    The XP usually taken by skeleton serpents is 10d6 + 2% of player experience. If you have hold life, you get a 95% chance to save; if the save fails, you lose 10% of the usual amount. So for a more advanced character, the .2% is much more significant than the (10d6)/10.

    Leave a comment:


  • Arralen
    replied
    Shopkeepers
    I'll have an eye one them. Actually, now that I'm looking for their names, those 2 are in charge of those shops. But I could swear that the keeper in Belegost changes during the last 100 000 turns, and the cap stayed at 5000. Guess everything will work ok now, at least as long as I'm paying close attention :/

    !Speed
    Guess I'm confusing variants again ...

    (rand)arts
    No, I didn't get (rand)art rings at lvl30 or below. Sorry not to make myself more clear ... I meant I get ego and (rand)art weapon (and to a way lower extent armor) at this level already, and have trouble with resistance holes and free action etc., so I normally can't spare a slot for something "simple" as a ring that gives +2 on a stat or +9 on damage.
    Btw., I think maybe something should be done about "item distribution" in almost all *bands .. you always easily get a sword, an armor, a cloak, because there are so many of them, but getting a ring or boots is quite a bit rarer. Or maybe it's the distribution-over-depth that makes my chars die before they get together the full gear


    "Resistance to life draining" - how does it work?
    Got it from my Angband weapon, and the "C"haracter screen simply notes "Hlife +" .. does it mean this is supposed to work 100% like free action, see invisible etc.?
    Up to now, those "W" and "V" weren't able to drain me, but a skeletons serpents spit attack seemingly did 329 XP "damage" .. it's listed as 10d6+, so it looks like it did full damage ?!
    Last edited by Arralen; February 23, 2009, 07:31.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by Psi
    The shop owners all have their own max price set in the edit files. You have just been unlucky if each one you have had has had the same 5k top price.
    There are two with a max of 5000, a Beorning (Bearclaw) and a Dwarf (Borin). It is reasonably likely for those two to be in charge in Khazad-Dum and Belegost; let us know if anything else happens.

    As for rings, as Psi says, Skill is great - very often useful (at least for a while) for anyone but mages and necros. Stat rings I frequently use when I can spare a ring slot - and I'd often rather have =CON for extra HP than resists.

    At least, often when I get to that depth. Currently I'm playing random characters,
    and am up to about 30, with only 2 of them (HE Ranger, HE Rogue) having reached Amon Rudh. Stupid game.

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzkill
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    Weapon Smith (in Belegost) is fixed to 5000 gold
    Actually, I haven't been paying attention if the other shops may be "fixed" as well, but this one is the most annoying to me atm I'm pretty sure the shop owner has changed several times, but the cap for prices has stayed the same.
    edit: Ok, went over to Khazad Dum and found the weapon smith having a cap of 5000 as well
    Maybe a 3.6 change, but it doesn't sound like something Nick would do. Probably the RNG or a bug. You can set recall points in other towns for expedited selling.


    !oSpeed is missing from the alchemy shops

    They're generally very scarce. I found 1 in the dungeon, and had 3 at the black market, but they seemingly never show up at the Alchemy Shop !
    I think the Black Market is the only place they naturally appear. I believe you'll find them most frequently on DL's 5-10 (based on experience, not spoilers). You can order them (once discovered) from the traveling merchant found in small towns.

    Leave a comment:


  • Psi
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    Weapon Smith (in Belegost) is fixed to 5000 gold
    Actually, I haven't been paying attention if the other shops may be "fixed" as well, but this one is the most annoying to me atm I'm pretty shure the shop owner has changed several times, but the cap for prices has stayed the same.
    The shop owners all have their own max price set in the edit files. You have just been unlucky if each one you have had has had the same 5k top price.
    Originally posted by Arralen

    !oSpeed is missing from the alchemy shops

    They're generally very scarce. I found 1 in the dungeon, and had 3 at the black market, but they seemingly never show up at the Alchemy Shop !
    The alchemy shop does not sell !Speed. You could always order them from the travelling merchants.
    Originally posted by Arralen
    Rings/Amulets of Searching/Skill/+stat+ are pretty useless,
    as by the time they show up aroud dlvl 30 you already have the first (rand)arts and you're looking to plug resistance holes rather than to get +2 searching or something. Either make them show up much earlier (dlvl 15+) or make them more interesting.
    IMHO, having one item "of something" seemingly just because we have some flag and it so terribly convenient to simply e.g. slab that flag on a ring to get a "magical item" doesn't really make for interesting finds. I would rather like to see more "complicated" egos, randarts and arts ... .
    =Searching is native to DL5, =Skill is native to DL25, =Stat is native to DL36. I'm somewhat concerned if you are finding (rand)art rings before that. I see no reason why skill and stat couldn't be a little shallower though.

    Certainly I rarely use the stat rings and never use searching, but =Skill is very useful. The Eregion rings may cover the "complicated" egos (they have speed, a power and one or more resists).

    Leave a comment:


  • Arralen
    replied
    Weapon Smith (in Belegost) is fixed to 5000 gold
    Actually, I haven't been paying attention if the other shops may be "fixed" as well, but this one is the most annoying to me atm I'm pretty shure the shop owner has changed several times, but the cap for prices has stayed the same.
    edit: Ok, went over to Khazad Dum and found the weapon smith having a cap of 5000 as well


    !oSpeed is missing from the alchemy shops

    They're generally very scarce. I found 1 in the dungeon, and had 3 at the black market, but they seemingly never show up at the Alchemy Shop !


    Rings/Amulets of Searching/Skill/+stat+ are pretty useless,
    as by the time they show up aroud dlvl 30 you already have the first (rand)arts and you're looking to plug resistance holes rather than to get +2 searching or something. Either make them show up much earlier (dlvl 15+) or make them more interesting.
    IMHO, having one item "of something" seemingly just because we have some flag and it so terribly convenient to simply e.g. slab that flag on a ring to get a "magical item" doesn't really make for interesting finds. I would rather like to see more "complicated" egos, randarts and arts ... .
    Last edited by Arralen; February 21, 2009, 14:57.

    Leave a comment:


  • Mr.Peanut
    replied
    Originally posted by Psi
    2. I've just tested with a Dark Elf without a light source during the night and I can see warm-blooded creatures within 20' as expected (when in LoS of course). At 30' I cannot see them - also as expected. Unlight allows reading in the dark anywhere.
    Ah. I didn't realise infravision would be so physically correct (and literal to its description). I expected to see in the dark.
    Like I said, noobly questions.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by Mr.Peanut
    4) Any idea when next DS port will be released(hopefully with "lazy move" option custom movement key delay time when not in menus)?
    I'm hoping to get a DS port of 0.3.6 out soon, but I'm having problems with my build setup. It won't have the lazy move option either. I can say that there will be more and better DS stuff happening in the future, and maybe one day the present.

    Leave a comment:


  • Psi
    replied
    Originally posted by Mr.Peanut
    1) Does detect traps permanently mark an area as trap free. Is that what the DTraps string in lower left corner means?
    2) I am playing a dark-elf, a race that has infravision, but at night in the wilderness I still can not see anything without a light. I don't understand. Is this only a dungeon effect? Does the unlight skill allow reading in dark in wilderness areas?
    3) Best weapon choices for dark-elf assassin?
    4) Any idea when next DS port will be released(hopefully with "lazy move" option custom movement key delay time when not in menus)?
    1. Yes
    2. I've just tested with a Dark Elf without a light source during the night and I can see warm-blooded creatures within 20' as expected (when in LoS of course). At 30' I cannot see them - also as expected. Unlight allows reading in the dark anywhere.
    3. Something light like a sabre.
    4. One for Nick maybe

    Leave a comment:


  • Mr.Peanut
    replied
    A Few Noobly Questions

    1) Does detect traps permanently mark an area as trap free. Is that what the DTraps string in lower left corner means?
    2) I am playing a dark-elf, a race that has infravision, but at night in the wilderness I still can not see anything without a light. I don't understand. Is this only a dungeon effect? Does the unlight skill allow reading in dark in wilderness areas?
    3) Best weapon choices for dark-elf assassin?
    4) Any idea when next DS port will be released(hopefully with "lazy move" option custom movement key delay time when not in menus)?
    Last edited by Mr.Peanut; February 19, 2009, 17:48.

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzkill
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    Few low-level characters would be able to detect the bigger vault - would you spend several ?oMap on every mountain level just because of a slighty-better-than-nothing level feeling?
    So, you don't find the vault. What's the big deal?

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by Psi
    A ranger is still drastically easier than the poor mage (but that is a whole new issue to be tackled).
    This is one of my big tasks for 0.4.0. Mages should be almost unrecognisable by the time I'm finished with them. My rough plan is for them to start out with low damage (as now) but more tricks, and build to have decent damage at the end which can be improved with more trickery.

    Morgoth was modified in a previous version. He gained elemental immunity (he only resists poison in O), his spells were improved but he went from 30 to 20 speed. I've but him up to 25 in 036, but wouldn't be averse to him back at 30.
    This was done for thematic reasons - I really wanted him to be more of a summoner than a fighter. I think I'd rather increase his summoning (or some variant of it) than speed.

    Thanks again for all the comments. I'd be very interested in other opinions too, because if I am in the minority, then Nick may wish to arbitrate and make appropriate changes in 040!
    I'm liking early game rangers; late game you'll probably have to ask someone else...

    Leave a comment:


  • Psi
    replied
    Originally posted by Atriel
    5. Probably the most important:
    Ok...lets make a start then. I could be here a while. First some background... my first ranger win was Anadyn. Bandobras noted on the dump: "Out of curiosity: weren't the late-game arrows too powerful and the early-game too weak? (changes in O 1.1 suggest these)" which I wholeheartedly agreed with. My next ranger winner was Bogspotter who beat Morgoth without losing a single hitpoint. I then won with Psironic who defeated Morgoth as an Ironman ranger with a x4 bow and Totila, though admittedly she struggled with archery (I had found no brands/slays that affected Morgoth) and resorted to melee. I then won again with Reg before I started making my own changes.

    To make the changes I took a level 50 ranger equipped with Bregor and built a table of average damages with various dice arrows. I also looked at criticals and the affect of brandings.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    The changes made in missile damage seem to be balance-breaking in two ways; I am bad with rangers and never won with a Ranger in [O] even having a couple that have gone down to dlvl 9x, clvl50, endgame equipment. (but won w ranger in [V], and already won twice-in-a-row [O] with warriors). I like warriors, but I feel that this change might have weakened the Ranger a lot. Also ranger have to collect, manage and enchant stacks of arrows, and when best arrows r gone, that's it, no more big damage. Ranger must fight in the open, vulnerable to summons and everything else.
    Yes, the changes weaken Rangers a lot in the end game (though they are now a lot easier at the start), but that is because Rangers became ridiculously powerful at the end. They make decent fighters, have a fantastic array of spells and can take down any single enemy from a distance with ease and almost in slow motion with the number of shots per turn.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    About the balance of RANGER and WARRIOR.
    In [V], a ranger with good equipment could easily do 1600+ damage per turn with its best arrows, while a warrior meleeing would hardly reach 1200 with a big weapon like Doomcaller and 2 RoDams, much less with other weapons. These calcs were done by Timo a long time ago in the RGRA, if i remember well. I don't know if this was changed from them and how tho...
    This only highlights how overpowered archery is in V - which is why you will see characters of every class getting a (+9,+9) longbow as soon as possible.
    In my mind a Ranger should do less damage than a warrior, simply because he has the massive advantage of doing it from a safe distance.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    I did myself some calcs (by the time of [O] 0.70) to compare [O] Ranger ranged vs Warrior melee, and figured that an elf ranger (best bow skill of all races, with skill equipment focus and build completely made for shooting, could crit ~40% of the time) in [O] would already deal less damage than Warrior melee, both with near-optimal equipment and good arrows; Breath attenuation in [O] balanced things out a bit in some situations;
    As I mentioned earlier - O 0.70 was considered to have too powerful archery in the endgame which is why arrow dice was changed in O 1.1. In which case the Warrior will do more damage still than the Ranger per turn (comparing melee to archery of course).
    Originally posted by Atriel
    Now, those changes made:
    - The ranger deal yet less damage late-game.
    Exactly what I was aiming for - and until I saw your thread I was actually thinking I hadn't done enough (and to be honest I'm still not sure).
    Originally posted by Atriel
    - Criticals now are UNCOOL and also do little added damage; Marksman is now a pretty weak spec. It was really cool to do a really big crit of 200+ damage (one shot in 100 or so) that would take out 2 stars of something big... and know that the next shot could take like 3 hp of my target heh...
    Well with endgame kit and ego enhanced ammo you can do over 200 *average* damage now. The main reason for 'squashing' the ammo into more dice was to eliminate the massive criticals you could get (and I mean massive). Criticals are still effective (extra dice always are), but not quite as ridiculous as they were.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    - The damage potential for the first tier missiles is in some cases, BETTER than of the second tier missiles! Of course, taking into account the finding of missiles with similar added dices. This could be fixed by making the late missiles have 2 dices instead of 3, with more damage; Of course, this apply only if the way [FA] calculates missile damage is unchanged from [O]...
    Yes, I've looked at all these things in great detail. However the changes you suggest effectively take damage back to where it was, which makes endgame Rangers a munchkinish option. I also like the way that 2d5 arrows are better than 3d3. It means that normal arrows don't become junk when seeker arrows become native.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    I am taking into account rapid shots too now as a spec, more valuable than marksman with the current missile dices; But still, it is only a spec; It seems balanced raising max shots from 2.5 to 3, but Athletics, Piercing Shot and Marksman (with old dices) were incredibly valuable, on par with the new Rapid Shots.
    Marksman is only of much use in the early game as it is not culmulative with the criticals you get anyway as a high level archer. Rapid fire is by far the best spec for a Ranger (and I had to tone that down considerably from the previous versions of FA where it gave an extra 2 shots at max dex!).
    Originally posted by Atriel
    My sugestions: either:
    - Leave damage as it was before, but lower all damages from the high-tier missiles; 1d6, 1d8 and 1d10 are already very good values for seeker shots, arrows and bolts respectively. This would make Marksman on par with Rapid Shots. and completely fix the uncool crits... but this might make the sling a little bit too weak for a rogue slinger late game, in this case, balance in the speed of shooting.
    What would you do about standard ammo though? 1d5, 1d6 and 1d7 are too low. Raise these and you are almost on top of your seeker ammo. Then what about enhanced ammo?
    Originally posted by Atriel
    - Make dices be in the middle range between before and now: Seeker Shot 2d4, Seeker Arrow 2d5, Seeker Bolt 2d6; This would also fix somewhat the uncool-critical weak marksman problem, but still marksman would be weaker than rapid shots.
    I looked at this last year some time. The problem is that 2d7 is just too high for an enhanced arrow - we could do this if we only allowed ammo to gain 1 additional side (I've already reduced this from 3 to 2 as it is).
    Originally posted by Atriel
    - Just edited in: How about 1d7, 1d8, 1dX for the seeker ammos? That way slings wouldn't be too weak, arrows would deal slighty less damage than before and slighty more than now, and i'm not sure about bolts... And then leave the first tier missiles multi-diced, as criticals have little effect in the start and the multi dices would make them worse later on.. Heck, thinking how closer the actual dices are now, could even be this way (normal and seeker): Shots: 2d3 and 1d6; Arrows 2d4 and 1d8; Bolts: 2d5 and 1d10; heh. Off to make a ranger to test...
    Unless you change the enhancement mechanic depending on the type of ammo, then enhanced 2d6 arrows have a better average than enhanced 1d10 seeker arrows.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    I agree with some points, but we must take into account that this dude (PSI) has nerves of steel and reflexes of a kilrathi and is very probably the best player of [O] combat variants and [FA]:
    Thanks, though I think that title (along with many others) belongs to evariste.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    >Rangers can do probably twice as much damage a round as a magic user (even taking misses into account)
    >and at the expense of just 3 or 4 arrows rather than 30-40 MP.

    Yea, but this is part of game balance; Magic users have only get the book and cast away, !restore mana, cast away...
    Rangers have to get arrows, enchant, preserve and save them, do all those boring arrow-related stuff... and good arrows don't last forever.
    Actually, the necromancer can deal more damage per energy than the OLD ranger with some damage builds (the extreme being Fastcasting, HMagic, Channeling and main spell:Mana Bolt(Frightful Realms), using only 7x energy per cast) and the mage is designed to be the king of utility spells for everything, not be a high-damage dealer anyway...
    Yes, but a ranger can also fight and has the best set of utility spells (for a non-full caster) going. A ranger is still drastically easier than the poor mage (but that is a whole new issue to be tackled).
    Originally posted by Atriel
    >Ranged attackers obviously have an advantage against Morgoth, because he is going to waste turns moving
    >whilst melee chars will get hit by Morgoth or by his spells every turn.
    >Another thing is that I may just have been lucky... I remember taking Psironic up against Morgoth
    >and she got hit by ancient dragon summons almost every time Morgoth came into LoS. Thankfully I was
    >only hit by one more after I lost my _BanishEvil otherwise things would have got really tricky.

    Yes, that's the point... The ranger is ranged, but do not have many choices to deal with the summons... Mages and necros already have their tools in their spell lists. I found it a pain killing mages with ranger in [O], especially the ones that could summon, because they deal full damage on me and also can call for their pets. In the other hand, most breathers go down easy.
    Then TO/blink/melee/whatever - the ranger is not a one trick pony.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    >I think I favour the speed increase - otherwise casters who go the charm offensive route could slow
    >Morgoth to +10 which is ridiculous. So I think +25 to speed and maybe the rest of the problem is still
    >more with rangers/archery rather than Morgoth himself (I find all uniques a lot easier with rangers).

    Hum... was Morgoth nerfed? This is bad. I usually tend to overprepare late game just to completely wipe the floor with him, going "huh, didnt think he was such a wimp". Ok, i know that against him i can use all the [O] *HARD EARNED* healing and consumables i've found thru the game (IE no wasting !heal against most midlvl uniques)... but in [FA] consumables are sooo easy to find and can also ask the town guys to get them that it would be already easier to deal with 30 spd morgoth...
    Morgoth was modified in a previous version. He gained elemental immunity (he only resists poison in O), his spells were improved but he went from 30 to 20 speed. I've but him up to 25 in 036, but wouldn't be averse to him back at 30.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    The ranger is also already pretty hard to play for an average player... having to balance everything and decide where to toss the best arrows.
    My point is that reducing the multipliers for slays and brands might be already a big nerf to the Ranger, reducing maximum damage, and this change might be on par with the fact that we have more of everything (including ammo) in [FA], but also messing with damage dice might be too much; Yes, the ranger can deal sometimes more damage per turn than some classes, but already less than melee fighting and less than some spellcaster builds, and has all the annoyances of saving and managing ammo. The reward for that i think should be damage slighty better than other classes, as long as his best arrows last.
    I disagree. I had to reduce the slays/brands because damage output was still so high *after* my dice changes.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    Then, i might be wrong in all of this... just my feelings of balance as it is now
    Thanks for all the feedback - it is much appreciated.
    Originally posted by Atriel
    I agree about "easier to start", but not with "harder to finish" because the ranger only is very powerful in the hands of an almost perfect player, as we can see in the ladder... Psi got all but one endgame or near-endgame Ranger... but lots of other players got endgame and near-endgame with every other class.

    Psi, if you check by, I'd like to hear your thoughts about Ranger balance and power compared to say, Assassin and Warrior too.
    Assassin: probably my favourite class. Good at everything. Well balanced throughout the game.
    Warrior: just ploughs through in the early game! I prefer characters with utility spells, but once you are kitted out they are fairly straightforward.
    Now Rangers... prior to 036 they were a pain to get going as early archery was so weak and it takes a while for their melee to get going. But once you did they were unstoppable. With a decent weapon and a heroism spell their melee is good enough for most enemies and anything vaguely tough you just line up down a corridor and let fly from your quiver. Rarely does a monster reach you before it is dead. Even with the changes in 036 I took down Gothmog with archery with Barkus and that was only a x3 bow. That character should have won but I was playing sloppily and failed casting Herbal Healing (another amazing spell for a Ranger) when I should have !Healed.

    My guess is that you try to kill everything with your bow (and hence your concerns about supply of arrows), whereas I use my sword where I can (and it is safe to). I wouldn't expect to attempt a pit with my bow for example. The thing is that one-on-one the Ranger is still supreme - uniques fall very (maybe too) easily. Yes, they are more vulnerable to crowds of monsters up close, but that is the trade off.

    Thanks again for all the comments. I'd be very interested in other opinions too, because if I am in the minority, then Nick may wish to arbitrate and make appropriate changes in 040!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕