Rogues in the current version

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Djabanete
    replied
    In Heng, ninjas have a spell called “Quick Walk,” which is a buff that makes walking take much less energy than usual (that is, you perform the directional movement action as though your speed were much higher, but all other actions are unaffected). It’s fun and very powerful from the early game to the late game, and it helps give ninjas a distinct feel from other classes.

    It could be a way to buff Rogues without needing to make changes in how stealth works.

    I like how it’s extremely useful in combat without being a buff to damage/AC/HP, which might feel out of place. It’s usefulness lies in allowing you to position yourself better, avoid getting surrounded, escape down corridors, create distance for ranged attacks, close the distance against ranged attacks… having superior battlefield positioning feels very “Rogue” to me in a game that’s fundamentally about combat (which is not what Rogues are fundamentally about).

    Edit: no idea what is going on with my phone and certain punctuation characters, sheesh.
    Last edited by Djabanete; May 11, 2023, 10:22.

    Leave a comment:


  • ewert
    replied
    Honestly, end-game doesn't really require you to kill many monsters, most people just play the hack n slash kill em all way. Including me.

    However, my last rogue winner just a few months ago, I actually ended up killing with wands the end uniques that were alive, and I think a Mace of Disruption for the undead uniques.

    I only dabbled with steal a couple times, but I could see how one could do that and teleport others for non loot carrying ones and just clear vaults and stuff for gear. Then grind simple things for the exp.

    I felt the new rogue was very nice in its niche.

    Leave a comment:


  • Cryomaniac
    replied
    Utility-related benefits (high stealth, detection, disarming, bonus experience) end up being less useful by the endgame; you could either make Rogue the designated 'comfortable early game, harder endgame' class, or add some specific benefits for the class, like bonuses for light weapons/armor, or something like Hengband's Ninja superstealth.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    One of the aims with the class re-vamp in 4.2 was to make the classes more distinct. So rather than rogue being "warrior with a bit of magic", I was looking for a distinct niche, and the obvious one is stealthy play. So they got worse melee, better throwing, great stealth and escapes, good device use and disarming, and stealing. The opinions in this thread (which seem to me to summarise general feelings about 4.2 rogues well) indicate that this has been unsuccessful. I think part of this is that stealing hasn't really caught on, probably because there isn't enough incentive to do it.

    So I think rogues need something (or things) extra. Here are few ideas, mostly inspired by similar character types in NPP/O/Sil:
    • Evasion;
    • Sneak attacks on unwary monsters;
    • Bonuses when wielding light weapons;
    • Ability to set monster traps;
    • Experience for stealing;
    • Superstealth/invisibility.

    Another thing to consider is an expansion of the monster sleep mechanic to include being awake but unaware of the player, and allowing rogues to exploit that.

    Leave a comment:


  • PowerDiver
    replied
    Rogue is now a difficulty option, like forced descent. If that's not what you are looking for, play another class.

    If you do play a rogue, put all of your initial stat points into str and dex.

    Leave a comment:


  • Pete Mack
    replied
    Estie said it: rogue got a little too nerfed. No more buff spells; just top notch detection, stealth, and haste self. The stats got nerfed again, IIRC, so melee is poor in the early game, as is HP. It used to be the go-to spell-warrior class; no longer. Paladin holds that role now.

    Leave a comment:


  • Estie
    replied
    Well a hobbit rogue with a sling of power is going to use ranged almost exclusively, while a HT rogue with a *thanc will just melee most things.

    Everyone else falls in between.

    Leave a comment:


  • Talharim
    replied
    Originally posted by Estie
    What do you mean by "prioritize" ?
    It was a bad choice of words. I meant if the main source of damage is usually melee or ranged. For instance, for ranger I guess it is ranged.

    At least my ranger seems to do much more damage with ranged than melee

    Leave a comment:


  • Estie
    replied
    ad1: Personally, I put everything into Str/Dex; some people prefer a few points into Con to decrease the grind time later.

    ad2: Rogue has become weaker in combat. Its hard to compare the spell set to the old version. As for melee vs ranged, use whatever is better for the situation. What do you mean by "prioritize" ?

    ad3: I liked the old version with stronger combat and buff spells better. I cant find much utility in the new books.

    Leave a comment:


  • Talharim
    started a topic Rogues in the current version

    Rogues in the current version

    Hi
    I was thinking about trying to play rogues in this version but I don't know:
    1. What should my stat allocation be?
    2. What are its strengths and weaknesses, specifically, how does it fare in combat? Should I prioritize a missile weapon?
    3. Do you guys prefer the current version of the Rogue or the old one?
Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕