I've actually gotten a *lot* of mileage out of devices when playing rogues (they get the Recharge spell), and it makes for a very fun, quasi-mage style of play. Through most of the early and midgame, you can do some pretty nasty damage with the various elemental wands by targeting enemy weaknesses (or at least not-resistances). Dragon Breath wands especially are glorious. And then of course, once you start getting Drain Life and Annihilation, you really start slaughtering things, especially when you use your Phase Door spell to keep your distance. Add to that the Rogue's unparalleled stealth, and detection, and my Rogue victories were honestly some of my smoothest.
Both times I beat Morgoth with a Rogue I did it by hitting him with Wands of Annihilation until he died.
Rogues in the current version
Collapse
X
-
I mostly play rogues because I like their stealth and detection.
I never use stealing. It's often so much easier just to kill a monster. The times where it could be useful, a sleeping unique who I can't kill, I find it's not reliable enough and can just create more problems.
I really think the rogue class needs a backstab ability, to make stealth a much more valuable asset. It could double the damage dice or something. It makes sense that stabbing a sleeping monster is more deadly than meleeing a conscious monster who is fighting back.Leave a comment:
-
I'm like Ingwe, rogue is my preferred class, though I lean to High-elf.
I think Nick did a great job with the latest version of the rogue. It is definitely its own little niche in Angband.
Not great (but not bad) at melee at the start, but so darn good at throwing and shooting. And hands down the best detection of any class. The first detection spell finds evil and life and the treasure detection spell is like a cheat code, telling you exactly what is where. Stealth helps.
The class is built for descending rapidly and making good use of most of what you find. Very flexible. Very fun.
BTW, I always play with selling on now. Finding that "Battle Blessings" book is still nice when you can sell it for 20,000K. I know it will eventually translate to something good - a rogue has a lot of options.
You just have pick your battles well and know what is lurking near by.
When I fail with a rogue it is typically because I picked a bad fight and didn't abort when I should have. Even with an early rogue I still have a bit of "see it, go hit it" mentality at times - don't do that
Leave a comment:
-
I like 4.2 rogues, and have won with them more than any other class. But they could use a few tweaks. One thing is that by the mid game, success rate for stealing is too low, so they essentially lose that ability. This should probably be fixed. The multiplier to damage when attacking sleeping monsters is a good idea, and gives a unique feel to class. I tried both these changes in tactical angband, and liked them.Leave a comment:
-
I can't quantify it, but compared to my memories from a decade ago, rogues seem to do significantly worse at melee.
For my experiments to see how the game has changed, I have not been diving. I wonder how many people care about stair detection other than serious divers.
Even when rogues say they have 100% disarming, sometimes chests explode while disarming. So my rogues still chose to carry -disarm. That's not precisely a weakness, but it was very irritating.Leave a comment:
-
I guess I'm an outlier, as Dunadan Rogue is my favorite class combination in the latest versions. And I've played every race/class combo there is.
Rogues remain a reasonably balanced fighter, have great stealth and trap disarming, and the ability to detect objects (not just *, but actually what the objects are), and to detect stairs, make for the best ability to dive deep and play fast.Leave a comment:
-
They actually did "live by their wits but could fight their way out of a tight space.*" The new rogue simply cannot do the latter. It had all the buffs and utility spells of mage and ranger, plus detect object, stealth, very good melee and archery, and solid HP and starting stats. The best all around class. What's not to like?
* quote from the user's manual.
Leave a comment:
-
Seeing as food value is a curse, and I'm sure I'm not joking now, at a minimum food effects should last as long as the food does. If you eat nothing but mushrooms of shadows, you should have continuous coverage IMO.Leave a comment:
-
I've stopped playing rogues. It used to be one of my favorite character classes to play, but it is not fun anymore. The changes ruined it. I would like it to go back to what it was before.Leave a comment:
-
I could see rangers getting a +move speed instead of the stealth, and give the stealth to rogues spellbooks. Or link it to the steal spell (so you get the stealth thingy after grabbing an item). I see fast movement more a ranger thing than rogue thing. Actually, just add the stealth function from the ranger spell to rogue phase door after lvlx for example.Leave a comment:
-
I feel this has already gone past that point; how about Nick continues with his thing and PD maintains vanilla ?Leave a comment:
-
Doesn't Ranger's NoTrack spell basically have the effect of making awake monsters not aware of the player?One of the aims with the class re-vamp in 4.2 was to make the classes more distinct. So rather than rogue being "warrior with a bit of magic", I was looking for a distinct niche, and the obvious one is stealthy play. So they got worse melee, better throwing, great stealth and escapes, good device use and disarming, and stealing. The opinions in this thread (which seem to me to summarise general feelings about 4.2 rogues well) indicate that this has been unsuccessful. I think part of this is that stealing hasn't really caught on, probably because there isn't enough incentive to do it.
So I think rogues need something (or things) extra. Here are few ideas, mostly inspired by similar character types in NPP/O/Sil:- Evasion;
- Sneak attacks on unwary monsters;
- Bonuses when wielding light weapons;
- Ability to set monster traps;
- Experience for stealing;
- Superstealth/invisibility.
Another thing to consider is an expansion of the monster sleep mechanic to include being awake but unaware of the player, and allowing rogues to exploit that.
A stealth level after Legendary that is Invisible?
BTW, who thinks that mushrooms of shadows need to last longer?
Maybe Rogues could get a +1 or +2 stealth bonus for lightweight armors. So armors with no to-hit penalty would give +2 stealth, armors with (-1) encumbrance would give +1 stealth and armors with (-2) encumbrance would give no stealth bonus. So soft leather armor of elvenkind <+2> would give +4 stealth to Rogues.
@Djabanete: so the spell equivalent of Quick Walk in Angband would be the new Angband mechanic: movement speed. We have haste self spell, why not, instead of haste self, Rogue gets +1 movement speed spell? (this would help differentiate from Ranger since Ranger gets haste self spell as well). Although I guess Druids have locked down these spells, but the difference here would be Rogue wouldn't have to make any sort of transformation in order to gain the movement speed.
If you really wanted to have fun you could give Rogue a final book spell (CL40 required) that costs 60sp that grants +2 movement speed and +2 stealth for a CL dependent duration (CL50 would get 75+1d75 turns, which is the =Tulkas activation duration). Otherwise they'd get an earlier +1 movement speed spell that costs 30SP.Leave a comment:
-
Pickpockets do not belong as player choices in this game. Nor do burglars. Nor barkeeps, nor blacksmiths, nor falconers, nor carpenters. For the record, I've won in variants with chars that specialized in trap setting and in forging, so my opinion is not uninformed.
Some guy put it well in another thread.
A burglar like Bilbo is a support class. If you want a sub-game where the hero Thorin sends Bilbo on a mission to steal the Arkenstone, fine, but Bilbo shouldn't be killing anyone important.In my opinion part of it is in the name. Angband is the fortress of the great evil of the world, Morgoth. Getting to the bottom of it, and killing him, is going to have to be epic. This is not a "let's go on a random Dungeon Crawl to kill some generic monsters and grab loot" exercise, it's an attempt to overthrow the Middle-Earth equivalent of Satan, defeating most of his minions along the way.
If you want a class for a thief, use perhaps the most famous thief in fantasy literature as your template. I refer to Conan, of course. He might team up with a sidekick burglar on occasion, but he's the one to overthrow Morgoth, not the sidekick. Now that I write this, I wonder whether Lupin is better known, but his type would never go on a quest where he would have to get his hands messy.
I like the idea of half-classes. Someone whose magic level is half his CL, or CL - 10, or whatever. They are fun to me. The way to differentiate them is to differentiate the underlying spell books. If you do a good job differentiating mage books from priest books, their half-classes differentiate themselves without any effort at all.
If you are going to make a new class, I beg that you design it so that it doesn't only work due to LOS abuse. If you insist on monster traps, those need to be an entirely new spell system to make any sense.Leave a comment:
-
The rogue plays like a squishy version of its former self, so yes its not great.One of the aims with the class re-vamp in 4.2 was to make the classes more distinct. So rather than rogue being "warrior with a bit of magic", I was looking for a distinct niche, and the obvious one is stealthy play. So they got worse melee, better throwing, great stealth and escapes, good device use and disarming, and stealing. The opinions in this thread (which seem to me to summarise general feelings about 4.2 rogues well) indicate that this has been unsuccessful. I think part of this is that stealing hasn't really caught on, probably because there isn't enough incentive to do it.
So I think rogues need something (or things) extra. Here are few ideas, mostly inspired by similar character types in NPP/O/Sil:- Evasion;
- Sneak attacks on unwary monsters;
- Bonuses when wielding light weapons;
- Ability to set monster traps;
- Experience for stealing;
- Superstealth/invisibility.
Another thing to consider is an expansion of the monster sleep mechanic to include being awake but unaware of the player, and allowing rogues to exploit that.
Stealthy play already exists, it is called diving and it is very different from conservative play. However, rogue does not have a stealth monopoly so its not class defining (and thats a good thing imo).
Evasion: Please no; if you want to introduce an additional layer of tankiness, give it to the warrior, he can use it (but dont call it evasion, instead give him damage reduction/level).
Sneak attacks on unwary monsters: Lets say, a doubling of the damage in the first combat round, would be a simple change that would warrant weakening the combat stats; kill it while it sleeps, if you cant do that, use wands or launcher instead. More elaborate versions like requiring light weapons or undead being immune could be considered but you approach the point where the mechanic just gets ignored, like current stealing.
Bonuses when wielding light weapons: weapon weight is already tied to stats/game phase; the only thing I can think of to add to that would be to make it so late game rogue prefers, say, Belangil over Aule (but he probably still wants Ringil). Good luck trying to hit that niche.
Ability to set monster traps: Now this has a lot of potential, but it also would be a lot of work. The issue I see with it is that it is at cross purposes with the traditional stealth skill, diving, because laying traps and luring monsters into them requires control of the environment.
Experience for stealing: If you want to fix stealing, just return it to the way it was implemented initially by not depriving uniques of later loot. Stealing, as the name implies, should be an additional source for items (and not xp or anything else).
If you really hate that idea, another way might be to make it worthwhile to steal from non-uniques. You could modify the object detect spell to also detect carried items in the area (and list them in the item window) so rogue would seek out that great Wyrm randomly carrying Wrath. I dont know how much work it would be to implement that, though, since carried items currently get determined on death.
Superstealth/Invisibility: I think stealth is very powerful already; more of the same doesnt make much sense, rather nerf stealth for everyone else. I wouldnt like that, though, just to make the rogue more unique.Last edited by Estie; May 11, 2023, 16:17.Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: