FAangband 0.3.6

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Pete Mack
    replied
    The fake-persistent levels idea is OK, so long as the same un-IDed items have a good chance of reappearing on the level each time you come back--as Nick says. You can't force regeneration of Ringil, but level-scumming is pretty much a necessity in FA, not for items, but for simply staying alive.

    You could do this by semi-persistently marking existing items for possible regeneration, but that's fairly complicated.

    Simply being forced to transit between Angband(61) to Anfauglith(56) is sufficient to make stair-scumming Anfauglith(58) plenty scary. In fact, this alone may be enough to solve the problem. Just don't generate any objects unless the player has gone at least two levels away from the generated level, not counting town levels.

    Leave a comment:


  • PowerDiver
    replied
    Originally posted by buzzkill
    I would really love to see and try this, if only as a beta/trial/hack version. Would it be very hard to implement?
    [talking about floor generation only the first time on a level]

    The problem is rebalancing the monster drops up a bit, but not too much. For a hack, you just ignore that. You would need to save an array of levels visited, so savefile compatibility would probably get mucked up a bit for live characters, and you would have to change or [more likely] disable the autoscummer. Implementing vaults would be the hard part. NPP has a solution I do not like, since I just cannot accept non-drop monsters like fleas with drops, but, for a hack to try this out, stealing that code is probably the simplest idea.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by PowerDiver
    in a non-persistent world, disconnected level resets are the best solution.
    Disconnected level resets I think would be a bad idea for the advanced races in FA - venturing out into level 28 as a High-Elf can get you killed easily even if you are on the 'stairs'. Persistence (or semi-persistence a la Entroband) would be a possibility, but I would have to really be convinced it was the right thing to do (as adding multiple levels to the savefile would be non-trivial).

    Force the player to pay a significant price in safety [as well as turncount] for a level reset. If that is too much for you, either allow floor objects only the first time a level is created, or not at all. If you want vaults, mark vault monsters with a flag that causes them to drop extra items and better items to make up for no items on the floor in a vault.
    I rather like this too. It allows 'stairscumming' in wilderness for safety purposes, without the 'redo level until you detect Ringil' mechanic.

    IMO, if things are bad when you minimize turncount, fixing those problems will result in a better game even for those who pay no attention to turncount.
    This is, of course, true. I had to have some sort of shot at these guys who finished the comp in a fifth of the turns that I used, but I wasn't aware quite how transparent I'd been...

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzkill
    replied
    Originally posted by Donald Jonker
    ... I don't think either myself or Buzzkill are qualified to make that call - we ought to be asking the all-stars at the top of the competition ladder....
    I agree, at least partly. It's good to have you back Donald. I was a little worried about you .

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzkill
    replied
    Originally posted by PowerDiver
    ... in a non-persistent world, disconnected level resets are the best solution. Force the player to pay a significant price in safety [as well as turncount] for a level reset. If that is too much for you, either allow floor objects only the first time a level is created..
    Me likey. Me likey a lot (in theory, at least). It would actually give players an incentive to explore levels that would otherwise be passed over in hope of better/deeper items (and not flee any level at the first sign of danger). It would place a whole new emphasis on staying power and survival rather than escape (TL/WoR/Stairs).

    I would really love to see and try this, if only as a beta/trial/hack version. Would it be very hard to implement?

    Leave a comment:


  • PowerDiver
    replied
    Originally posted by Nick
    While I'm philosophising, I'll say that I dislike excessive focus on turncount.
    I think you generally learn a lot by looking at the extreme cases. I'd say the lesson about scumming 56/58 is the same as everywhere else -- in a non-persistent world, disconnected level resets are the best solution. Force the player to pay a significant price in safety [as well as turncount] for a level reset. If that is too much for you, either allow floor objects only the first time a level is created, or not at all. If you want vaults, mark vault monsters with a flag that causes them to drop extra items and better items to make up for no items on the floor in a vault.

    IMO, if things are bad when you minimize turncount, fixing those problems will result in a better game even for those who pay no attention to turncount.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    The chief things that bother me are related to the issues that UnAndrew raise in his blog about a year ago (btw, pav - a link to the blog on the links page would be nice).

    It turns out that the current best way to get a good turncount in FA is stairscum on the Anfauglith 56/58 border - I tried this a few times last night with thralls, and my characters included one which had found Crisdurian, the Glaive of Pain and Caspanion by 5000 turns.

    I don't know about anyone else, but this seems unbalanced to me - not in a fairness sense, but in that it is an overemphasis on a small part of the game.

    While I'm philosophising, I'll say that I dislike excessive focus on turncount. For me, focus is on winning, with the expectation of enjoying the journey - certainly with my comp game win, I could have gone faster at the end but was still enjoying killing off uniques, so didn't. Once one has won a variant once, I understand that one needs new challenges, and winning as fast as possible is certainly a valid one. But there are others - different race/class combinations, or the (self-regulated) equivalent of Nethack's conducts, for example.

    I need to stop now before I start on instant gratification and the evils of modern society

    Leave a comment:


  • Donald Jonker
    replied
    Originally posted by buzzkill
    Getting it 'right'. That's the real trick, isn't it? I've a feeling that the definition of 'right' would vary greatly from player to player (not that the auto-scummer get it 'right' either).
    Balance is indeed what should be under consideration. "What is most fun?" should be the driving question behind any change to the autoscum system.

    No objection to removal 'of 'boring' levels, but I fear this may, in effect, make the game easier (although I don't have a ton of confidence in that statement). For some reason, I don't mind the auto-scummers existence in ironman mode. I think it's the combo of auto-scumming and stair-scumming that bothers me. Maybe, make it a birth option, force dis-connected stairs, and limit the up staircases to 1 per DL with auto-scum on. I've no idea how to handle this with FA's abundant wilderness.

    ... and eliminate level feeling with auto-scum on, or limit their scope to enemies, and ignore item feelings.
    This is emphatically *not* what should be under consideration. Difficulty should always be a subordinate issue to fun; sometimes they're the same, but when they're not, fun must take the fore.

    So the obvious question is: do people toggle autoscum because (a) it's fun or because (b) it makes the game more easy? If there's even the slightest inkling of reason (a), then you should think long and hard before changing the mechanic.

    Put another way, the emphasis should be on making 'normal play' (whatever that is) more fun, not on penalizing abnormal play (whatever that is judged to be) to make it less desirable. If abnormal play is more fun then it should be allowed and unimpeded until better ideas are brought forth.

    The only real reason we should want to discontinue autoscum as a toggle-option is because it's tedious to go into the options and toggle it, not because it defies some vague notion of 'virtuous play' that Buzzkill is perennially and bafflingly so concerned with. Only boring play should be punished, and we haven't established that toggle autoscumming constitutes boring play. Frankly, I don't think either myself or Buzzkill are qualified to make that call - we ought to be asking the all-stars at the top of the competition ladder. Whatever "cheating" is in FA is a matter of accrued experience, not theory.

    The ideal would be a fully balanced game without autoscum, but before then, I say leave the virtuous play to those who care about virtue (who can treat the autoscummer as a birth option whether it exists as such or not), and let everyone else have fun.

    Leave a comment:


  • Zikke
    replied
    Maybe another birth option with the AutoScum toggle could be a value between 1-100 on the AutoScummer threshold as to how "crazy" a level needs to be to count on the autoscummer?

    Just brainstorming

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by buzzkill
    Getting it 'right'. That's the real trick, isn't it? I've a feeling that the definition of 'right' would vary greatly from player to player (not that the auto-scummer get it 'right' either).
    Yes, so with autoscum you have two different approximations to right.

    I have the beginnings of a scheme to deal with this, which essentially involves having for a minimum target 'score' for a level. One obvious question with then is 'should the score be more like current with or without autoscum?'. And one obvious answer is that you can actually set a 'difficulty level' at birth. Note that 'easy' would not mean easy here; it would mean less out of depth monsters and objects. This opens the can of worms of multiple difficulty levels, too.

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzkill
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    IMHO, it does not make sense to generate 1 000 000... better generate levels "right" on the first try, and make most items interesting for most of the game.
    Getting it 'right'. That's the real trick, isn't it? I've a feeling that the definition of 'right' would vary greatly from player to player (not that the auto-scummer get it 'right' either).

    It's impossible to (really) balance the game for both cases - you end up with too boring "boring levels", too good "good levels" and all other sort of hassle.
    This, in effect, is balance, though not perfect. It may be as close as you are going to get, given random dungeon generation.

    While at it, "preservation" could be removed/reworked as well.
    Couldn't artifacts be 'locked' to only (and/or always) appear on the DL where they first appeared. Thus, if you decide pass on a {superb} level, that particular item(s) will not be found again unless you return to this DL to search for it.

    Ok, so let's say the scummer is removed, and item rarities tweaked (up?)
    Should make balancing easier, and (hopefully) remove -really- boring levels.
    No objection to removal 'of 'boring' levels, but I fear this may, in effect, make the game easier (although I don't have a ton of confidence in that statement). For some reason, I don't mind the auto-scummers existence in ironman mode. I think it's the combo of auto-scumming and stair-scumming that bothers me. Maybe, make it a birth option, force dis-connected stairs, and limit the up staircases to 1 per DL with auto-scum on. I've no idea how to handle this with FA's abundant wilderness.

    ... and eliminate level feeling with auto-scum on, or limit their scope to enemies, and ignore item feelings.

    Leave a comment:


  • Rizwan
    replied
    Originally posted by Daniel Fishman
    Thematically, they're "lost" already, aren't they? So even if "they're very hard to find again once lost" is true (and I'm not convinced by it) that would make them very hard (equally hard, indeed) to find in the first place.

    I'm not convinced on gameplay grounds either, but I'm struggling to formulate why not.
    Quite right! If they are generated on a level and you don't find them then they are still lost and you have a chance (really the same chance as finding them in the first place, again) of finding them at some other time and place

    Unless you want to generate persistent levels and then generate the artifacts at a specific place. Without persistent levels loosing an artifact seems absurd because with randomness you can't go back to a place to search for something. Artifacts don't move themselves in real life. So if you miss something you should be able to go back and search for it again. Or if you say that the bad guys keep moving the artifacts then the current model is pretty good for that scenario as you get a chance to search for it somewhere else
    Last edited by Rizwan; March 5, 2009, 07:21.

    Leave a comment:


  • Daniel Fishman
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    In Tolkiens works, real artifacts have been proven to be very durable (The Ring, the short swords from the wight graves, Glamdring ...), yet they're very hard to find again once lost, so you better grab them if you get the chance... . Gameplay-wise, it's much more interesting to have the player actually fight for some Überweapon, then simply have him drop down another level or 2 because it will show up again anyway.
    Thematically, they're "lost" already, aren't they? So even if "they're very hard to find again once lost" is true (and I'm not convinced by it) that would make them very hard (equally hard, indeed) to find in the first place.

    I'm not convinced on gameplay grounds either, but I'm struggling to formulate why not.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by Arralen
    autoscum
    IMHO, it does not make sense to generate 1 000 000 Levels each time you go up or down, just until you get one which is "interesting enough". Just as it does not really make sense to generate hundreds of low-quality items, only to squelch them later on. Better generate levels "right" on the first try, and make most items interesting for most of the game.
    Precisely. The autoscummer is actually a big hack, presumably introduced in the first place to mimic what players were doing anyway to cover inadequacy in level generation. Just like squelch as a solution to the junk problem.

    game balance
    It's impossible to (really) balance the game for both cases - you end up with too boring "boring levels", too good "good levels" and all other sort of hassle.
    Agreed again.

    ... the scummer is removed, and item rarities tweaked (up?)
    Should make balancing easier, and (hopefully) remove -really- boring levels.
    This is a good aim.

    ... level feelings only give a hint about dangerous monsters (respawn depends on level feeling, too, doesn't it?), but not about items on the floor. I'm not sure about {special} feelings for artifacts, though.
    Interesting - I'll think about this one.

    ... preserve is always "on" (it is since 0.3.0, ain't it?), but artifacts left behind (IDed or not) only "respawn" with very low probability.
    In Tolkiens works, real artifacts have been proven to be very durable (The Ring, the short swords from the wight graves, Glamdring ...), yet they're very hard to find again once lost, so you better grab them if you get the chance... . Gameplay-wise, it's much more interesting to have the player actually fight for some Überweapon, then simply have him drop down another level or 2 because it will show up again anyway.
    This is a most intriguing idea. The chief problem I can see is that wilderness levels are not really designed to be exhaustively searched (at least, not always); in particular, it's frequently necessary to retreat, particularly with advanced races. So I think this would not work as it is, but it is food for thought.

    Thanks for the suggestions - you've given me lots to think about.

    Leave a comment:


  • Arralen
    replied
    autoscum
    IMHO, it does not make sense to generate 1 000 000 Levels each time you go up or down, just until you get one which is "interesting enough". Just as it does not really make sense to generate hundreds of low-quality items, only to squelch them later on. Better generate levels "right" on the first try, and make most items interesting for most of the game.

    game balance
    It's impossible to (really) balance the game for both cases - you end up with too boring "boring levels", too good "good levels" and all other sort of hassle.

    preservation
    While at it, "preservation" could be removed/reworked as well.

    Ok, so let's say ..
    ... the scummer is removed, and item rarities tweaked (up?)
    Should make balancing easier, and (hopefully) remove -really- boring levels.

    ... level feelings only give a hint about dangerous monsters (respawn depends on level feeling, too, doesn't it?), but not about items on the floor. I'm not sure about {special} feelings for artifacts, though.
    IMHO, in Middle Earth you can "sense" powerful creatures, sometimes, but even the few really powerful artifacts appear quite elusive, and "vaults" (not the monsters within), appear quite un-sensable to me.
    Furthermore, I want the player to explore the dungeon fully, not skip levels until he stop to scum for statgain, then skip again 'til he scums for some special artifact etc. (Could !oSTAT be artifacts, and therefore singular, too?). With a non-boring dungeon, this should actually enhance gameplay. And if the player insists on hurrying, he should at least have to invest in extended detection to make shure he does not leave anything valueable behind ...


    ... preserve is always "on" (it is since 0.3.0, ain't it?), but artifacts left behind (IDed or not) only "respawn" with very low probability.
    In Tolkiens works, real artifacts have been proven to be very durable (The Ring, the short swords from the wight graves, Glamdring ...), yet they're very hard to find again once lost, so you better grab them if you get the chance... . Gameplay-wise, it's much more interesting to have the player actually fight for some Überweapon, then simply have him drop down another level or 2 because it will show up again anyway.

    Would this make for an interesting, fun game?

    Leave a comment:

Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕