I always play with Autoscummer on. It makes it exciting. Otherwise the game seems like a grind.
I also support the idea of a birth option.
FAangband 0.3.6
Collapse
X
-
...on the other hand, playing O with autoscum is usually regarded as suicideNo surprise here, but I'm entirely for this. Players use the auto-scummer for one reason, because it works. It produces superior results vs. typical play. It produce superior results vs. stair sum play. It provides not only better items but better high XP enemies for quicker leveling. I'll stop short of calling it cheating (since it's included in the game), but it's damn close. I never use the auto-scummer in non-competition play, because it feels a lot like cheating to me. Not every level should be a gold mine.
There's no XP penalty in O/FA.In lieu of removal, there could be penalty or cost associated with auto-scummer, as there are with the super-races, like XP/2.
I think I'm going to have to imitate takkaria and make my sig "It's not going to be a birth option".IMO it should also be a birth option.
Given that the autoscummer has been untouched since I forked FA from O, having a rethink of it seems like a no-brainer (so I'm ideally qualified
). And, as Psi has pointed out numerous times, Anf 58 is a special case, and may need to be treated as such anyway.
Leave a comment:
-
I'll agree wholeheartedly with that point as it creates a different gaming experience... and I'd wholeheartedly dispute the rest
I'd be delighted for the autoscummer to be removed - providing the game is made as interesting without it as it currently is with it...Leave a comment:
-
No surprise here, but I'm entirely for this. Players use the auto-scummer for one reason, because it works. It produces superior results vs. typical play. It produce superior results vs. stair sum play. It provides not only better items but better high XP enemies for quicker leveling. I'll stop short of calling it cheating (since it's included in the game), but it's damn close. I never use the auto-scummer in non-competition play, because it feels a lot like cheating to me. Not every level should be a gold mine.
In lieu of removal, there could be penalty or cost associated with auto-scummer, as there are with the super-races, like XP/2.
IMO it should also be a birth option.Leave a comment:
-
I'm not denying that the shape and rules for Anf58 will affect art generation. I'm just not convinced that the effect is that big. Have you tested the rate of art generation with autoscum off in thrall mode? I'd be suprised if it was very different to autoscum on. I think its much more related to the player seeing a significant chunk of the open area available for item drop on desert levels (exacerbated by the 1/2 size of 58).The problem with Anf58 is that it is a diagonal cross section, so is only about half a level. It also has a dungeon entrance which prohibits vaults being formed on the level. Therefore the level feeling is entirely made up from half a level's worth of objects and OoD monsters.
This was also the case in FA035, however what changed in 036 was that artifacts had more of an effect on level feeling. Therefore in 035 the autoscummer would often reject levels with artifacts on for not generating a high enough feeling whilst egos did generate good feelings. Now in 036 those levels that the autoscummer rejected with artifacts are now being accepted and hence the rise in artifact sightings in Anf58.Leave a comment:
-
The problem with Anf58 is that it is a diagonal cross section, so is only about half a level. It also has a dungeon entrance which prohibits vaults being formed on the level. Therefore the level feeling is entirely made up from half a level's worth of objects and OoD monsters.
This was also the case in FA035, however what changed in 036 was that artifacts had more of an effect on level feeling. Therefore in 035 the autoscummer would often reject levels with artifacts on for not generating a high enough feeling whilst egos did generate good feelings. Now in 036 those levels that the autoscummer rejected with artifacts are now being accepted and hence the rise in artifact sightings in Anf58.Leave a comment:
-
The (very strong) impression I get from playing many *bands, with autoscum on and off, is that it only really matters below ~lvl50. Deeper than that level, if relatively few arts have been generated (ie. thrall of powerdiver), they start to become common whether autoscum is on or off. As an FA thrall, I ignore level feelings completely (I'm seldom on the level long enough to get one). I also think the high frequency of arts on Anf58 is partly a consequence of 0 energy edge scumming - you can look at a million levels and consume no game time until a longsword 4d5 is generated next to the entrance! This is actually the best winning strategy for the comp, but I for one, lack the patience.I think the critical issue here is the large chance of getting an artifact in Anfauglith 58 with autoscum on. This has arisen because there was a bug in autoscum, which (O and then) FA had been optimised around; Psi found and fixed it in 0.3.6, with some unexpected consequences. One way to deal with this is to make Anf 58 (and other dungeon entrance levels) a special case in the autoscummer. This seems to me kind of like fixing a symptom of a deeper problem, though. Here are some not entirely random thoughts:- Autoscum generally could be set to a lower level, or the ratings for level feelings overhauled;
- Autoscum could be removed entirely;
- Level feelings could be removed entirely;
- Level feelings could be redesigned (either in a minor or a major way);
- Unlight gives the darkness bonus in wilderness at any time unless there is actually a light breath or spell. That's a bug.
- The weightings for the various things that add to the level feeling could be tweaked.
Leave a comment:
-
I think the critical issue here is the large chance of getting an artifact in Anfauglith 58 with autoscum on. This has arisen because there was a bug in autoscum, which (O and then) FA had been optimised around; Psi found and fixed it in 0.3.6, with some unexpected consequences. One way to deal with this is to make Anf 58 (and other dungeon entrance levels) a special case in the autoscummer. This seems to me kind of like fixing a symptom of a deeper problem, though. Here are some not entirely random thoughts:- Autoscum generally could be set to a lower level, or the ratings for level feelings overhauled;
- Autoscum could be removed entirely;
- Level feelings could be removed entirely;
- Level feelings could be redesigned (either in a minor or a major way);
- Unlight gives the darkness bonus in wilderness at any time unless there is actually a light breath or spell. That's a bug.
- The weightings for the various things that add to the level feeling could be tweaked.
Leave a comment:
-
Then maybe you'll take Speedy3's word for it
. I definitely think Morgie needs beefing up, with speed +30 at the minimum, and probably more HP's (preferably immediately - I think Psi and everiste need a bit more of a handicap)!
Leave a comment:
-
Nick writes:
It occurs to me that you should verify this with a character who is not wearingI think Psi is right, and Morgoth needs to go back up to +30 speed.
l) The Pair of Hard Leather Boots of Feanor [3,+15] (+15 to speed)Leave a comment:
-
i dont have a copy of the silmarillion at the moment, but maybe there's some relevant magic that could be pulled from the story and used as ideas for new spells. if you havent already i mean. maybe more and rarer spellbooks or items that allow certain special spells if your magic device ability is high enough along with characters that cant eventually learn all their available spells. specialist abilities are tough since they really change the balance of the game, but maybe again there's something in the book that could be used. crossover stuff like limited magic ability for warriors or weapon specialization for mages & necros (or everybody) could be cool.Leave a comment:
-
Yeah I'm thinking of dumping the Rods I've picked up, though I might bank them in case I find an uber light source.Leave a comment:
-
In O, it activates for id - however it can have bad effects if you are a caster of any description and do not have >20 SP (or something like that). I think it can paralyse you through FA IIRC. For warriors it is a bit better, but will periodically confuse you even if you have rConf.
In FA, I have changed it as Rods of Perception are now so common. Basically whilst equipped it will autoid anything you pick up.Leave a comment:
-
What is the Stone of Lore? I couldn't find it in the O spoilers....
edit: Nevermind O_o I figured it outLeave a comment:
-
@nick--in almost all classes there are some abilities that are just better.
Unlight and Mana burn are the two most obvious, because Assassin and Rogue are so common in FA. But Fury is another--it's so obviously a useful skill for early warriors.
Beyond that, I don't know because I've almost never played other classes.Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: