The damage from thrust away seems about right to me- for damage output its weaker than the elemental spells, but hurts nearly everything. The problem is that the knockback is too effective.
If you made the knockback based on the proportion of the targets total health inflicted rather than the base damage, I think it would tone the spell down into something a lot less abusable. You'd still be able to send the cannon fodder flying, but anything dangerous you would be barely able to keep away.
I'm also seeing some crash, seems to be related to lots of objects (occurs around big vaults, or when clearing dragon pits or the like, was able to stop it by destroying objects). Or it could just be that Morgoth has learned how to save scum...
edit: heres a graph of dam/turn and dam/mana for the spells I currently have with a l48 mage: http://img.ie/876a0.png
FAangband 1.1
Collapse
X
-
Thanks for this - my high level spellcaster experience is fairly limited...
Having that high a fail rate is not intended behaviour - I'll revisit that.1) wall of force is way too weak, useless, while it is supposed to be 'ultimate' mage's spell, 17% minimum failure removes any possibility to even consider to cast this spell.
Noted - I've had my suspicions about thrust away for a while.2) cacophony and thrust away are slightly too strong.
Agree to both - that's a good idea.3) black breath is not good spell for necromancer, should go to assassin, have way lower level req. and mana cost, while necro may have something else here, HP -> MP conversion spell seems to fit well.
Good point about magic disarm. If you felt like changing any of these and testing in your branch, that would be great - I am more focused on deeper structural issues at the moment. In fact, I might look into making it easier for you and others to make changes - how do you feel about bazaar (Launchpad) versus git (github)?4) there are many other too weak and useless spells e.g. rogue's magic disarm, but I am concerned about high level useless spells first.Leave a comment:
-
I have some thoughts about FAangband spells, and want to know other's opinions about this subject.
1) wall of force is way too weak, useless, while it is supposed to be 'ultimate' mage's spell, 17% minimum failure removes any possibility to even consider to cast this spell.
2) cacophony and thrust away are slightly too strong.
3) black breath is not good spell for necromancer, should go to assassin, have way lower level req. and mana cost, while necro may have something else here, HP -> MP conversion spell seems to fit well.
4) there are many other too weak and useless spells e.g. rogue's magic disarm, but I am concerned about high level useless spells first.Leave a comment:
-
No. I'm sorry.
You shouldn't be getting anything to do with SDL. I make by going to the src directory in a terminal and doing 'make -f Makefile.osx'.
But the .dmg should be fine. I really don't get it. Mine looks like this.Leave a comment:
-
Also running Snow Leopard. Tried to compile and got this:I'm too tired to muck with it much right now, sorry.Code:Undefined symbols: "_SDL_GetError", referenced from: _init_sound_sdl in snd-sdl.o _init_sound_sdl in snd-sdl.o _init_sound_sdl in snd-sdl.o "_SDL_Init", referenced from: _init_sound_sdl in snd-sdl.o "_SDL_Quit", referenced from: _close_audio in snd-sdl.o ld: symbol(s) not found collect2: ld returned 1 exit status make[3]: *** [faangband] Error 1 make[2]: *** [all] Error 1 make[1]: *** [subdirs] Error 1 make: *** [all] Error 1Leave a comment:
-
That's very odd - mine doesn't behave like this at all. I wonder if it's an OS version issue - I compiled it and am running on Snow Leopard. What version are you using, and can you compile and run and see how it goes?Hm, better, but it's still not using the full screen.
And yes, this is the 1.1.5 OSX binary download.Leave a comment:
-
Artifacts have a 25% chance of uncursing with every attempt. The first attempt has no chance of blowing up, but after that the chance of that is 25% too. So you were lucky, but not extraordinarily.
HM answered this oneEvil Iggy isn't evil. Seems odd.
Leave a comment:
-
Actually warriors are best for the early to mid game, because you can actual fight orcs off. Later on you really need to find ESP and/or detection. Rangers in V are a bit easier because you have detection spells and resist spells. Its just getting over the first 20 lvls without getting killed by orcs that you can't out run or phase away from. Mages in V are pretty hard until you get a lot of spell points/spell books. Then you can get rid of Z's or whatever else you don't want to deal with. FA makes you deal with Z's in vaults though...plus TO doesn't beam like in V. This can be either good or bad. Mostly bad IMO.Leave a comment:
-
I noticed the same thing about Calris. I got it up to +9 with no luck getting it uncursed that way, and then I went through 2 *remove curse* and then maybe 6 regular remove curse scrolls with no explosions.
I think Evil Iggy is a tribute unique to a player who kept finding ways to beat Moria. I remember coming across him while reading about the history of Moria and Angband. I think he is only evil in regards to the RNG who he often defied. It's really more like Cunning Iggy than Evil Iggy, I suppose. I would give him the same alignment of rogues and brigands whatever that is.Leave a comment:
-
I totally agree on High-elf warrior. My two winners are vanilla high-elf warriors. But i just figured out that mages can survive unless they fight orcs or wormtongue(actually he would be a pushover if not for him doing frost bolt twice in a row).Good, because I think that Winged Dragons of Storm do much more damage with that Storm attack than they should. Maybe if they were worth more exp. But I've an easier time dealing with Smaug, or most other Winged Dragons including some which are worth more exp. But I actually like the fact that you can't just kill everything really easy...like in V. Great job on making the difficulty ramp up. I feel like the best games do this, a perfect example would be Cave Story. I just keeps getting harder and harder. A lot of games seem to reach a point where they level out until you finish the game. V tends to do this especially if you play a high elf warrior.Leave a comment:
-
Couple of things I've noticed...
Can artifacts actually be destroyed by uncursing. I went through a whole _RemoveCurse on Calris before it finally uncursed. I expected it to blow up well before then.
Evil Iggy isn't evil. Seems odd.Leave a comment:
-
Go into interface options and set bottom_status to no, and see what that does.
It still looks a bit strange to me - is it V1.1.5?
Edit: Another question - does it still look like this outside the town? And I assume you are playing on OSX - is this correct?Last edited by Nick; December 1, 2010, 23:10.Leave a comment:
-
So I decided to try something different from Vanilla for a bit, and downloaded FAAngband. And already I have a question: how do I get it to make use of the full-sized main screen? Right now it looks like this, which I'm sure you agree is a bit silly. And after all this time playing variants that support arbitrarily-sized main dungeon views, playing with anything else is downright claustrophobic.Leave a comment:
-
Good, because I think that Winged Dragons of Storm do much more damage with that Storm attack than they should. Maybe if they were worth more exp. But I've an easier time dealing with Smaug, or most other Winged Dragons including some which are worth more exp. But I actually like the fact that you can't just kill everything really easy...like in V. Great job on making the difficulty ramp up. I feel like the best games do this, a perfect example would be Cave Story. I just keeps getting harder and harder. A lot of games seem to reach a point where they level out until you finish the game. V tends to do this especially if you play a high elf warrior.Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: