Crafting system

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Gauss
    Adept
    • Aug 2018
    • 110

    Crafting system

    Are there any plans for a crafting system?
    For example alchemy for potions, blacksmithing for weapons/armor and inscription for scrolls.

    Artifacts should not be craftable in my opinion for lore reasons.
  • Derakon
    Prophet
    • Dec 2009
    • 9022

    #2
    I for one am staunchly opposed to crafting in Vanilla. 98% of crafting systems in videogames just encourage tedium, by giving the player minor advantages so long as they're willing to collect and hoard useless crap. 1% of the remainder has the Sil problem, of making the game impossible to balance, and the other 1% is basically the Teleglitch approach where there's a strictly limited supply of craftables and you choose what loadout you play with by what you make out of the ingredients (e.g. do I use this metal tube to add a barrel to my shotgun, or as a component in my enemy-detecting radar?). That works okay in a survival-horror type game where the player's resources are strongly limited, but it's impossible in Vanilla where there's a limitless supply of resources.

    If you want crafting, stick to variants. ToME 2 had the Alchemist class which had crafting. It was also by an order of magnitude the most grindy way to play the game.

    Comment

    • Nick
      Vanilla maintainer
      • Apr 2007
      • 9647

      #3
      I had no plans for crafting even before Derakon stuck his oar in
      One for the Dark Lord on his dark throne
      In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie.

      Comment

      Working...
      😀
      😂
      🥰
      😘
      🤢
      😎
      😞
      😡
      👍
      👎