Just looked at the UT32 tileset now... not really sure what you're going to use in there for Cat Warriors, Assassins, and cat uniques. Also, Sil has a lot of balrogs, and they're all pretty distinct -- that was one of the advantages of that other tileset, there were like a jillion dudes on fire in there.
I had a hard time finding good choices for serpents, but i guess even the
normal snake tiles would be OK.
Raukar can probably be selected from random different tiles as appropriate, but it will be hard to thematically associate them, I think.
The rest of the choices look pretty good, though.
Edit: Now I'm not sure what I mean when I say "other tileset". I thought I saw one that was comparatively "serious looking" (one of the balrogs looked exactly like Durin's Bane from the LOTR movies), which was what I was referring to above -- but looking at the Gervais tiles, those are definitely not it.
Edit2: Some great Final Fantasy I influences in some of these tiles lol
Edit3: Which one of these dudes is supposed to be Morgoth????
I had a hard time finding good choices for serpents, but i guess even the
normal snake tiles would be OK.
Raukar can probably be selected from random different tiles as appropriate, but it will be hard to thematically associate them, I think.
The rest of the choices look pretty good, though.
Edit: Now I'm not sure what I mean when I say "other tileset". I thought I saw one that was comparatively "serious looking" (one of the balrogs looked exactly like Durin's Bane from the LOTR movies), which was what I was referring to above -- but looking at the Gervais tiles, those are definitely not it.
Edit2: Some great Final Fantasy I influences in some of these tiles lol
Edit3: Which one of these dudes is supposed to be Morgoth????
Comment