Help me find a variant, please (details inside)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • DanielKennethRego
    replied
    Okay, I've decided to fully immerse myself in either FAAngband or NPPAngband. I'm a bit confused about the differences between them though, apart from the obvious that FAAngband is thematically based in the First Age and rids itself of items and monsters not relevant to the first age, and the fact that it has a wilderness that NPP does not.

    Can anyone briefly run down the significant differences between NPP and FA so I can pick?

    Leave a comment:


  • fizzix
    replied
    Originally posted by DanielKennethRego
    One more question, I thought Skills Angband/SAngband looked pretty cool, did any currently developing variant use those ideas?

    I tried NPPAngband and FAAngband, by the way. Both very cool and fun, but after playing Crawl for the past several months, I'm finding it hard to adjust to the slow early game in Angband-style games.
    You can play FAAngband as one of the elves where you start as level 5 and have a dangerous environment off the bat.

    However, the general design philosophy of Angband itself is that the first few levels are tame so that new players can get their feet wet. But there's no need to explore them if you've played a bit. Angband is very different from crawl in that clearing levels, while possible if you enjoy it, is not at all necessary.

    Leave a comment:


  • DanielKennethRego
    replied
    One more question, I thought Skills Angband/SAngband looked pretty cool, did any currently developing variant use those ideas?

    I tried NPPAngband and FAAngband, by the way. Both very cool and fun, but after playing Crawl for the past several months, I'm finding it hard to adjust to the slow early game in Angband-style games.

    Leave a comment:


  • Mondkalb
    replied
    Originally posted by DanielKennethRego
    This is exactly why I asked for relevant spoilers. I don't think situations like these are fair, where you are encountering a monster for the first time and it has the power to instakill you without you knowing what to expect. I remember Angband Vanilla had these aplenty back in the day (I even savescummed some characters out of sheer frustration), but Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup, for example, almost never has situations like these, at least in my experience. I like that.

    Do any of the major Angband variants take measures against this, by the way? NPP or FA?
    FA has a touch of cruelty in some ways. Even potions of detonation and death are still around. You can also find some pretty nasty cursed armor and curses on jewelry are quite common.

    Leave a comment:


  • DanielKennethRego
    replied
    Scatha, I'd *LOVE* it if magic somehow made its way into Sil, or at least someone took up the task and made a variant. With no offence to your work with Sil (which actually is the most impressive new roguelike I've played in years), if Sil were to have a proper skill-based magic system and more diversity and variety in the monsters, items and dungeon layout/terrain/design, it'd skyrocket to being the best roguelike today, in my opinion.

    I know both offensive magic and expanding the monsters and items lists beyond the original appearances in true Tolkein is contrary to your goals with the flavour of Sil, though. So maybe someone could make a variant. That would really be amazing.

    I love the whole abilities system in Sil, and how well implemented it is - that you can only trigger them by proper tactical thought and positioning. For instance, ToME also has a 'rush' ability like Sil does. Except in ToME, you can rush in from anywhere, any direction (as long as you are within a fairly large range limit), by activating the talent. It sounds cool at first, like a targetted blink with a free attack, but there's almost no tactical depth to it after you've done it 20 times. Now in Sil, to get that rush in effect (Charge), you need to move and position yourself accordingly. That makes the ability much more tactically relevant, and makes combat in general so much more involving. Great work, you and 'half'!

    Leave a comment:


  • Derakon
    replied
    There are cheat options in Angband (and, I believe, in all modern variants), one of which is to know the full monster memory. Personally I don't have a problem with people who use that option. Then when you see a new monster, your monster memory should include a complete listing of everything it can do to you. In Vanilla it'll also tell you the max damage each spell attack can do; dunno if that's the case in FA or NPP, but at least for breath attacks you can calculate it by dividing the monster's health by 3 (or, IIRC, 6 for the high elements excepting poison).

    Leave a comment:


  • Scatha
    replied
    Originally posted by DanielKennethRego
    But I really, really miss magic. I almost wish someone made a fork of Sil that introduced magic (responsibly, so as to not take away from the tactical and positional emphasis of the game - make range and terrain hazards significant in magic use, for example). It could really be the best roguelike I can imagine, then.
    A few people have made similar comments about missing magic. It has made me wonder about how you'd fit a good balanced magic system into the game. It's an interesting problem, and I have a system half-designed. I'm not going to release a variant, but I might write up a design doc explaining the rules I'd use in case anyone else wants to make use of it.

    Leave a comment:


  • DanielKennethRego
    replied
    Originally posted by Mondkalb
    Well, the fun is over ... ^^




    *Sniff*, this was the best one in FAangband so far ...
    This is exactly why I asked for relevant spoilers. I don't think situations like these are fair, where you are encountering a monster for the first time and it has the power to instakill you without you knowing what to expect. I remember Angband Vanilla had these aplenty back in the day (I even savescummed some characters out of sheer frustration), but Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup, for example, almost never has situations like these, at least in my experience. I like that.

    Do any of the major Angband variants take measures against this, by the way? NPP or FA?

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzkill
    replied
    Originally posted by Philip
    Isn't FayAngband Halls of Mist now? It has interesting light and terrain management.
    Yep, but I assume Fay 1.1 or 1.2 is still available. I tried playing Mist for a while, it had potential, but I don't think it was ever really finished. Fay is what I'd call a finished/stable variant, though no longer maintained. I suspect the name change had at least a liitle to do with preserving Fay as it's own entity.

    Leave a comment:


  • nppangband
    replied
    Originally posted by DanielKennethRego
    Also, with these variants like FAAngband and NPPAngband, where does one look for help and information about the game beyond the help files? I mean spoilers and such?
    There is a fan site for NPP (the link is in my autosignature). It was overrun by spambots, so I only do manual registrations at this point. But without registering there are lots of spoilers and tactical discussions to be read. You can also post any question you want here at oook and I can provide as spoilerish answer as you want.

    Also, the game has detailed help files that should tell you most of what you want to know.

    Leave a comment:


  • Mondkalb
    replied
    Originally posted by Mondkalb
    I wager this makes the game more fun, at least I'm making better progress with my current char than with any other before.
    Well, the fun is over ... ^^

    Wiruin, the Maelstrom breathes frost ... How is that even possible? It's not in his description.
    Also, the char went from over 600 to -275. OK, there's only 40% cold resistance, but still this is what a great Iceworm would cause.


    *Sniff*, this was the best one in FAangband so far ...

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by Mondkalb
    Nick is always watchful.
    Well, mostly.

    Leave a comment:


  • Mondkalb
    replied
    FAangband has some ingame help. (The corresponding .txt files are in /lib/help if you prefer to read them outside the game.)
    If you really want spoilers, you could still create them in the old fashioned vanilla way. (Make a new char, enter debug mode with "ctrl-a" and press " to generate spoiler files for monsters and objects; they will be placed in /lib/user/.) This savefile will be marked.

    But, spoiler files are lame.

    Better ask in the forums, some players here are playing FAangband and Nick is always watchful.
    Last edited by Mondkalb; February 9, 2014, 12:23.

    Leave a comment:


  • DanielKennethRego
    replied
    Also, with these variants like FAAngband and NPPAngband, where does one look for help and information about the game beyond the help files? I mean spoilers and such?

    Leave a comment:


  • Mondkalb
    replied
    I really like FAangband for many reasons. It has a bit more variety in character races and classes than vanilla. Also, the specialities you can choose and achieve add more to this variety.
    Divergent from Angband you get four magic schools.

    FAangband has different starting towns, depending on the race of your character. An assortment of distinct wilderness levels connects the towns and dungeons. Playing in wilderness is quite different from vanilla dungeon play stile - the wide open plains are more dangerous to unexperienced starting characters.
    Various terrains have impacts on game play, both monsters and player chars may be hindered by certain terrain types or could use them to hide or progress faster than their opponent.

    You can use up to four recall points to make travelling a bit more easy.

    All terrain types can occur in some dungeon places or can be created by chaos breaths.

    FAangand offers a plethora of magical jewelry with more abilities, benefits, penalties, or curses. Because the game uses a percentage resistance system you might want to keep them all, but the inventory is as limited as in vanilla. Except, you can store throwing weapons in your quiver, including artifact daggers or spears.

    Some of the monsters and uniques have different abilities than their counterparts in vanilla, so better be carefull. ^^

    Every now and then you may encounter special themed levels, which are fun and dangerous.

    In the newest version of the game Nick has streamlined the design a bit, shortening the travel time by thinning out the connecting wilderness regions.
    I wager this makes the game more fun, at least I'm making better progress with my current char than with any other before.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕