Improving Z+Angband

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    Well what I think of your list is easy, 'cos my good twin wrote it out for both of us.
    Very good.

    I now exit this debate (with apologies for the threadjacking), confident that that I have made my point, yet not having an unrealistic expectation that I have changed other people's minds in the process.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    I am not suggesting a causal connection, I am attempting to indicate a hierarchy of badness.

    I rank "making all arts too common" much higher on my hierarchy than "creating a no-brainer kit decision".
    Oh right, happy to agree with that too. I accept that I have in the past made mistakes in attempts to remove no-brainers which have actually been worse than the no-brainers themselves. I will probably continue to do so occasionally, but hope that it will happen less often and be more swiftly fixed.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    This is well trodden ground and I understand your position, and I'm sure you understand mine (well, you must do after fielding all the annoyed comments from players who don't like changes that have been made).

    I still think that if there was a written list of V design principles, which there isn't and probably shouldn't be, then "first do no harm" should be on it.
    Well what I think of your list is easy, 'cos my good twin wrote it out for both of us.

    IMO the key issue is the use of the term "official version". Takkaria was very careful to label the entire 3.1.x series as "beta" releases. He decided that 3.1.3 should actually be 3.2.0, and I have wondered whether this is in some way caused some problems, but I think most people here are pretty comfortable with the development model: lots of change, a little bit haphazard, with the occasional backward step among the forward progress. And all much more pronounced if you play nightlies.

    The alternative is little change, but much more carefully thought out and without any hiccups. That's what angband was like for years, while maintainers sought first to do no harm ...

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    I don't understand the strawman: removing no-brainers does not require making all arts more common. I accept that you have no problem with a few no-brainer kit choices, but I don't understand what you fear would happen if they went away.
    I am not suggesting a causal connection, I am attempting to indicate a hierarchy of badness.

    I rank "making all arts too common" much higher on my hierarchy than "creating a no-brainer kit decision".

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    I never find the darn thing so I wouldn't know whether it was a shield or a bar of soap.

    > IMO those are both prices worth paying

    My value judgement is the opposite. I don't have a problem with a few no-brainer kit choices, I'd much rather that than (strawman) making all arts more common.
    I don't understand the strawman: removing no-brainers does not require making all arts more common. I accept that you have no problem with a few no-brainer kit choices, but I don't understand what you fear would happen if they went away.

    Looking at the other post now.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Derakon
    Change, on its own, is good, even if it is the wrong change. If you don't want things to change, you can play a previous version of the game. It's not going anywhere. Even change that everyone agrees was a bad idea is still good, because a) it's easily reverted in 99% of cases, and b) it gets people to think about why it was a bad idea and help them understand what changes will be good ideas.

    You're going to have a lot of trouble finding a maintainer willing to just implement UI improvements while leaving the base gameplay alone. Maintainers take the job so they can tinker with the game, and that includes gameplay.

    That said, of course changes get a lot of review before becoming official versions. That's what the nightlies are for. I don't expect every change in the nightlies to make it to an official release -- though at the same time, the vast majority of the changes I've seen so far are good ones, albeit occasionally unpolished.
    This is well trodden ground and I understand your position, and I'm sure you understand mine (well, you must do after fielding all the annoyed comments from players who don't like changes that have been made).

    I still think that if there was a written list of V design principles, which there isn't and probably shouldn't be, then "first do no harm" should be on it.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    Right, well, then we do agree, but then I think you don't agree with the "anti-grinding" leg of the Crawl philosophy. The DCSS guys explicitly seek to make grindign impossible.

    Which good on them, but I don't think it's right for Angband.

    A.

    P.S. I think the Crawl crew were explicitly motivated by the desire to make Crawl "less like Angband". Fine and dandy, but I don't think the correct response is to seek to make Angband less like Angband.
    Agreed again. I think the hierarchy of angband's development needs looks like a bit like this:

    1. Ensure that grinding is not necessary or required
    2. Everything else I want to do
    3. Ensure that grinding is impossible

    So I am not totally at odds with the Crawl guys, but I don't assign it a high priority.

    Incidentally, there is another, unstated element of the Crawl philosophy, which is the reason I stopped playing it: opacity. Crawl doesn't want you to know what the to-hit formula is, or how weapon skill affects damage output, or have any quantitative knowledge at all. Remember how Angand used to have the categories like "Legendary", "Heroic", "Good" etc. for all the abilities, and now some of them have been replaced with actual numbers? Well Crawl is the opposite - everything in the game is opaque (except +hit,+dam,+ac, last time I looked). I hate that.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    No offence taken - this is exactly how I like to explore disagreements.

    I understand your point much better now. You are right that both "let's go look for the No-Brainer" and "I've got it, I can stop looking now" disappear if you take away no brainers. IMO those are both prices worth paying: I think "let's go look for an awesome item" and "I've got an awesome item, I can stop now" are close enough for this not to be too painful - whereas the benefit from removing the no-brainer kit choice is IMO huge.

    Thorin is a shield, btw, but no worries.
    I never find the darn thing so I wouldn't know whether it was a shield or a bar of soap.

    > IMO those are both prices worth paying

    My value judgement is the opposite. I don't have a problem with a few no-brainer kit choices, I'd much rather that than (strawman) making all arts more common.

    What did you think of my suggested list of V design principles?

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Derakon
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    - The game should be winnable using a broad spectrum of playstyles
    - Whatever the playstyle, the game should be hard to win
    - Since players are going to have to spend a lot of time if they are going to win the game, there should be a lot of content for them to experience
    - It is better to change nothing than to change the wrong thing. (In official releases, that is.)
    - Fine, to the extent possible. Variety is a good thing, but it is also very hard to implement while keeping everything balanced. This is, I suspect, one reason why NetHack hasn't had an official release in eight years.
    - Yes. Difficulty is good. Easy games do not promote replay as strongly as hard games doe.
    - No problems with more content. I think it'd be neat to have a little webapp "monster maker" where you could plug in stats and the app would generate the appropriate entry as well as tell you how hard the monster is compared to others in its depth.
    - No. Change, on its own, is good, even if it is the wrong change. If you don't want things to change, you can play a previous version of the game. It's not going anywhere. Even change that everyone agrees was a bad idea is still good, because a) it's easily reverted in 99% of cases, and b) it gets people to think about why it was a bad idea and help them understand what changes will be good ideas.

    You're going to have a lot of trouble finding a maintainer willing to just implement UI improvements while leaving the base gameplay alone. Maintainers take the job so they can tinker with the game, and that includes gameplay.

    That said, of course changes get a lot of review before becoming official versions. That's what the nightlies are for. I don't expect every change in the nightlies to make it to an official release -- though at the same time, the vast majority of the changes I've seen so far are good ones, albeit occasionally unpolished.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    I'm trying to tread a fine line and be very provocative without being at all obnoxious, hope I get it right.

    My point is not that the (former) superiority of Thorin over all other boots created no-brainer decisions which enhanced fun.

    It is that the (former) superiority of Thorin was not a problem - because the key gameplay element was not the kit decision ("Thorin or my other boots") - it was the search ("Gee I wish I had Thorin, let's go look for it in that vault") and the newbie learning experience ("Hey, these boots are the best you can get! I don't need to look for any other boots now") and the diver's problem ("Here I am at 4500' and I don't have Thorin").

    If you add a second set of artifact boots just as good as Thorin, then you make the kit decision more interesting but all the other experiential elements above are unchanged or reduced.

    If (strawman) you make both Thorin and the second set of boots more common - so that the player more frequently gets to make the interesting kit decision - then the situation is even worse.

    A.
    No offence taken - this is exactly how I like to explore disagreements.

    I understand your point much better now. You are right that both "let's go look for the No-Brainer" and "I've got it, I can stop looking now" disappear if you take away no brainers. IMO those are both prices worth paying: I think "let's go look for an awesome item" and "I've got an awesome item, I can stop now" are close enough for this not to be too painful - whereas the benefit from removing the no-brainer kit choice is IMO huge.

    Thorin is a shield, btw, but no worries.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    Ah, now here we agree. I am happy for grinding to be *possible*, I just don't want it to be *required*.
    Right, well, then we do agree, but then I think you don't agree with the "anti-grinding" leg of the Crawl philosophy. The DCSS guys explicitly seek to make grindign impossible.

    Which good on them, but I don't think it's right for Angband.

    A.

    P.S. I think the Crawl crew were explicitly motivated by the desire to make Crawl "less like Angband". Fine and dandy, but I don't think the correct response is to seek to make Angband less like Angband.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    Wow, I don't think I've disagreed with a post so much in a long time. We are on totally different wavelengths.

    (a) and (e) are not relevant to the issue of whether something is a no-brainer or not (because it has to be found to trigger the issue)

    (c) and (d) are null if it's a no-brainer. This is the whole problem with no-brainers: you *don't* have to adjust anything!

    (b) might be a fair point, but in 11 years I have never seen or heard of a newbie who didn't instantly realise that Thorin was a no-brainer.
    I'm trying to tread a fine line and be very provocative without being at all obnoxious, hope I get it right.

    My point is not that the (former) superiority of Thorin over all other boots created no-brainer decisions which enhanced fun.

    It is that the (former) superiority of Thorin was not a problem - because the key gameplay element was not the kit decision ("Thorin or my other boots") - it was the search ("Gee I wish I had Thorin, let's go look for it in that vault") and the newbie learning experience ("Hey, these boots are the best you can get! I don't need to look for any other boots now") and the diver's problem ("Here I am at 4500' and I don't have Thorin").

    If you add a second set of artifact boots just as good as Thorin, then you make the kit decision more interesting but all the other experiential elements above are unchanged or reduced.

    If (strawman) you make both Thorin and the second set of boots more common - so that the player more frequently gets to make the interesting kit decision - then the situation is even worse.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    Yes I am absolutely serious.

    > By definition, nobody likes grinding

    I don't think 'like' is quite the right word for the benefit or satisfaction that one gets from the grinding experience. 'Has fun' would also be the wrong word. And yet people do it.

    > The best angband example is probably worm farming. .... If something about the game's design meant you *had* to do it, that would be ... awful

    True. But if a change to the game design meant you could no longer do it, that would suck.
    Ah, now here we agree. I am happy for grinding to be *possible*, I just don't want it to be *required*. Others go further and don't want it to be even remotely beneficial. IMO the current balance is about right: you can worm farm if you want, but after a certain cl it's more or less negligible in XP value, and they drop nothing.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    Ha! I hoped you'd say that.

    If a player could readily find both Thorin and an equally good alternative, then yes, that would lead to a challenging decision - wield Thorin or wield the alternative.

    The status quo, however, is better because it leads to several points of challenge:
    (a) somehow obtain Thorin AND
    (b) realise that it is the best alternative AND
    (c) adjust kit to deal with having it AND
    (d) adjust playstyle in response to your new capabilities, OR
    (e) somehow do without Thorin (as a diver often has to do).

    A.
    Wow, I don't think I've disagreed with a post so much in a long time. We are on totally different wavelengths.

    (a) and (e) are not relevant to the issue of whether something is a no-brainer or not (because it has to be found to trigger the issue)

    (c) and (d) are null if it's a no-brainer. This is the whole problem with no-brainers: you *don't* have to adjust anything!

    (b) might be a fair point, but in 11 years I have never seen or heard of a newbie who didn't instantly realise that Thorin was a no-brainer.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Camcolit
    Crusade against no-brainers
    Anti-grinding
    Interface
    I would think a more appropriate set of design philosophies for V game play (as distinct from code design, collaboration or interface design) might read something like:

    - The game should be winnable using a broad spectrum of playstyles
    - Whatever the playstyle, the game should be hard to win
    - Since players are going to have to spend a lot of time if they are going to win the game, there should be a lot of content for them to experience
    - It is better to change nothing than to change the wrong thing. (In official releases, that is.)

    A.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕