It all depends what you find fun in a 'band. Personally I don't think I'd care much for black curses because I'm not a challenge-junkie: these games are plenty hard enough for me as they are. And what I like is powering up and taking on interesting challenges... and a challenge to avoid black curses may not be much fun. So maybe this is more of a good idea for an ironman mode than a standard feature.
I think the urge to have curses is one based on realism more than anything else. It just doesn't make sense that with so much evil magic in the dungeon, and adventurers exploring it that rely so heavily on equipment, that there wouldn't be curses designed to hinder or kill adventurers.
What we need: More heavy curses
Collapse
X
-
I think that if you're going to include cursed items, the player ought to be tempted to use them. The gameplay value comes from player decisions: is it worth enduring the curse to use this item?If curses are going to add any really interesting flavor to the game, they have to be (1) not deadly and (2) very hard to discover.
If the curse is deadly then the item will never be used, so deadly curses are not very interesting from a gameplay perspective. But if the curse is hard to discover, as you suggest, then the player isn't making an informed choice (or any choice at all), and the curse is similarly uninteresting.
One way to tempt players might be to make curse activation very rare. For example, consider an aggravation curse which has a 1 in 1000 chance of aggravating every creature on the level. The curse must be significant enough that its activation is a non-trivial event, but rare enough that the player isn't annoyed.Leave a comment:
-
Wielding an unknown curse for VUL_FIRE would be instadeath. You can't have that, because then you make items that have even a small possibility of it gone from potential use. Or you make players scum for a salamander so they can compare damage. Neither of those are very appealing.A couple of interesting ideas.
First of all, curses that are easy to discover are not dangerous, they just make you adjust your gameplay to avoid them. Negative effects are only really interesting on mixed blessing items, if they are obvious or easily discovered, such as the standard mixed-blessing items in V. If curses are going to add any really interesting flavor to the game, they have to be (1) not deadly and (2) very hard to discover.
So the idea might be that items can rarely have a "black curse" flag which makes all negative or potentially negative effects undiscoverable (except through meta-game reasoning, of course). A black curse item with CURSED would stick to you when you wield it but you could not discover it was cursed, even with ID or *ID*, without trying to put it on. A black curse item with VUL_FIRE would be particularly nasty: you take substantially more damage from fire, but you can only realize it's happening by noticing that fire monsters are doing more damage than they should. Better figure that one out before you tangle with an AMHD! It might not be too hard to figure out a black curse item with AGGRAVATE on it but it could be temporarily dangerous. The black curse flag should apply not only to negatively enchanted things, it should be possible on just about anything. And that should include store-bought items: in fact, black curses should be so well hidden that all the hidden flags, including BLACK_CURSE itself, should not affect object value. So you can sell black cursed objects to a store once you figure it out, and they won't know and will pay full price... and sometimes things you buy from them will have black curses and you won't know.
And I like the idea of new curses that can have one object affect other objects, such as draining charges or rods, or disenchanting things, or making things cursed, especially when the flags are hidden.
Perhaps *REMOVE CURSE* can have a chance of removing the black curse flag for items you are wielding.
I'll never understand the obsession with curses I guess. To me they're just an annoyance that get in the way of fun gameplay. I think if you're going to add another feature, especially one that makes the game harder, you need to ask, 'how annoying will this be?' If the answer is, 'substantially' then it's a no-go.Leave a comment:
-
A couple of interesting ideas.
First of all, curses that are easy to discover are not dangerous, they just make you adjust your gameplay to avoid them. Negative effects are only really interesting on mixed blessing items, if they are obvious or easily discovered, such as the standard mixed-blessing items in V. If curses are going to add any really interesting flavor to the game, they have to be (1) not deadly and (2) very hard to discover.
So the idea might be that items can rarely have a "black curse" flag which makes all negative or potentially negative effects undiscoverable (except through meta-game reasoning, of course). A black curse item with CURSED would stick to you when you wield it but you could not discover it was cursed, even with ID or *ID*, without trying to put it on. A black curse item with VUL_FIRE would be particularly nasty: you take substantially more damage from fire, but you can only realize it's happening by noticing that fire monsters are doing more damage than they should. Better figure that one out before you tangle with an AMHD! It might not be too hard to figure out a black curse item with AGGRAVATE on it but it could be temporarily dangerous. The black curse flag should apply not only to negatively enchanted things, it should be possible on just about anything. And that should include store-bought items: in fact, black curses should be so well hidden that all the hidden flags, including BLACK_CURSE itself, should not affect object value. So you can sell black cursed objects to a store once you figure it out, and they won't know and will pay full price... and sometimes things you buy from them will have black curses and you won't know.
And I like the idea of new curses that can have one object affect other objects, such as draining charges or rods, or disenchanting things, or making things cursed, especially when the flags are hidden.
Perhaps *REMOVE CURSE* can have a chance of removing the black curse flag for items you are wielding.Leave a comment:
-
I like it, but then again, I'm easy (and not not the who may someday have to implement it).
I'm thinking, at it's most basic, something like this.
A inheritable-curse sword (-4,-4). It feels deathly cold. Trying to immediately unwield the sword results in the "is welded to your hand" message. Remove curse would function normally. However, even without remove curse, there is would be an cumulative % chance (from 1%-10% depending on CL and type of curse) that after each use (attack), that the owner would be able to drop it, and by doing so transfer some or all of the curse to himself, to be removed (via remove curse, blessing, whatever) at a later time, when a means of doing so become available. In the meantime, the player could then wield a more useful weapon, thus partially negating the curse.
It could be applied to most, if not all, types of curses and items. Inherited-curses that are ignored (not removed in a somewhat timely manner, 1000's of turns?), could strengthen over time, even faster if many curses are present, corrupting the soul in unison.Leave a comment:
-
For completeness, here's the FA list:
" induces random teleportation",
" prevents teleportation",
" aggravates nearby creatures",
" occasionally greatly aggravates nearby creatures",
" slows your regeneration",
" makes you afraid",
" speeds your digestion",
" occasionally poisons you",
" randomly envelops you in poison",
" occasionally cuts you",
" will suddenly cause deep wounds",
" sometimes makes you hallucinate",
" will suddenly leap from your grasp",
" makes demons suddenly appear nearby",
" calls the undead from their slumber",
" cannot be dropped from your pack",
" sticks to you if wielded",
" will briefly paralyze you",
" can paralyze you even if you feel immune",
" drains experience",
" drains mana",
" will sometimes lower a stat",
" will take energy from your magic devices"Leave a comment:
-
-
Random idea: what if curses got transferred to the player (rather than being stuck to the item)? This eliminates the "I'm stuck using a worthless item" angle but also means that curses can keep stacking up until (appropriately) removed.
It seems like it would be easier to make strong curses that aren't game ending this way. It would also be easier to have lots of interesting names/descriptions of the various curses affecting the player which have been either cast directly by an enemy or transmitted via an item.Leave a comment:
-
In this thread I advocate the inclusion into Vanilla of more items that have both positive and negative effects. Although it's pretty old (I think it's from 3.0.8 days), it has a lot of crossover with this thread so I thought it might be fun to peruse again.
To contribute more directly, here are some possible curses, off the top of my head:
-Item slows regeneration
-Item taxes your mana (increases all mana costs by some small amount)
-Item prevents you from having 0% fail rate (can only get 1% at best)
-Item is disenchantable --- cannot be enchanted, and can be disenchanted even if you resist.
-Weapon sometimes polymorphs monsters upon hitting
-Weapon sometimes teleports monsters away upon hittingLeave a comment:
-
I think there are two separate things here. I have most experience in V so my response will be based off of it.
Curses - bad things that happen to you because of a misstep, these are the "can't take off" weapons in V. These vary from being a significant hindrance until you find a way to get rid of it (Ring of the Dog) to things that will kill your character outright (morgul weapons) We'll split these into two groups. Game-ending bad items, and game-delaying bad items.
Mixed good/bad items - Things that you can choose to wield, but have a drawback. This would be like your 'evil' weapons that have some undesirable effects.
Game-ending items. In order for these to be an addition to the game they must be fairly rare. You want only a small number of games to end because of a morgul weapon. Let's say in an average game you test-wield 100 items, and you want the chances of dying to a morgul weapon to be around 5%. That puts the probability of a weapon being a morgul weapon at 1-0.95^(1/100) = 0.0005. Any more and you make test-wielding not worth the risk.
Game-delaying items. If you put on one of these items you are forced to recall back to town and scum for remove curse. These become a hindrance in a normal game, but their real effect is in ironman games, where they can be death. Test wielding jewelry is an option in regular games but is not so much of an option in ironman games. Personally, i wouldn't mind these items being eliminated.
Overall cursed items are annoyances. Increasing their annoyance makes identifying more necessary. If identify doesn't reveal curses, a wary adventurer needs to just buy all weapons and armor from town. I don't think anyone wants that.
Mixed-benefit items. I think this is where your approach should be. Generally the trick with mixed-benefit weapons is that the drawback should be significantly less than the benefit. This isn't really the case with many of the early rings, except for the situational escaping and teleport. In the late game the only real drawbacks are aggro and drain exp. Aggro is enough for me to chuck any weapon with it unless it's Morgoth-killing quality. That is probably the only time in the game where I'm able to afford aggro. Drain exp is a joke in the endgame.
However there are so many other ways to make mixed-benefit items. For example shields which give you immunity (!) to one element but give vulnerability to another (negates resistance or gives +50% damage if unresisted) Weapons which have very large damage multipliers but sometimes add to your stun counter when wielding.
To sum up my opinions. Keep game-ending heavy curses very rare. Eliminate minor curses. Make lots of weapons, armor and jewelry with mixed-benefits where the benefit outweighs the drawback.Leave a comment:
-
Curses that don't show on initial id. Unlike FA's they shouldn't show on specific ego's.
Noone said things need to be that^ fair.Leave a comment:
-
You should really have a look at Nicks FAAngband curses.
They're ... hmmmm ... great, in a sense .... *mumblemumble*
Leave a comment:
-
Ancient and foul, kinda like my ex-wife, but seriously... my aim, though maligned, is to make the game more interesting. There's a wide variety of items that are good, but only a few types of cursed items, and those aren't even necessarily sticky anymore. Minus to hit, minus to damage, minus to AC, it's all very mundane. Let's create a set of creative curses both mild and severe that will keep the player guessing, entertained, and hopefully not too terribly upset (when he's polymorphed into a snaga and slain by a novice paladins).Leave a comment:
-
If you really want an evil curse you can copy this from Z - http://www.zangband.org/spoilers/tycurse.txt
Good old Topi knew how to teach those newbs to ID before wielding and watch where they step.Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: