Zangband revival?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • konijn_
    replied
    Originally posted by Jude
    On the topic of healing, can we have potions of CCW not suck? I use them and they give me back maybe 20-30 hp, which the monster I'm fighting then knocks right back off on its next turn. Seems to me like these type of potions should be more useful...
    Potions of Curing should heal more.

    T.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jude
    replied
    On the topic of healing, can we have potions of CCW not suck? I use them and they give me back maybe 20-30 hp, which the monster I'm fighting then knocks right back off on its next turn. Seems to me like these type of potions should be more useful...

    Leave a comment:


  • Rizwan
    replied
    Also mushrooms can be eaten by ghosts but not shattered by cold or burnt by fire or destroyed by electricity like potions and staves and rods which do the same things as the mushrooms. So you can have some protection if your potion of restoration gets shattered don't worry you still have that mushroom (you can get restored AND high all at the same time )

    Leave a comment:


  • Citybob
    replied
    I think there should be more delicious mushrooms - like morels, shitakes, and chantarelles. Wonderful mushrooms that satisfy the palate, sharpen the mind, and stengthen the body! More mushrooms please!

    Leave a comment:


  • Zikke
    replied
    I always thought there should be a whole lot higher percentage of Mushrooms of Sickness or Mushrooms of Hallucination than are in the game. I mean, if you find a mushroom somewhere, chances are it's just going to be a mushroom and probably either make you sick, make you high, or just make you a little less full.

    But then again I also thought there would be more Potions of Water lying around but there aren't..

    Leave a comment:


  • Mangojuice
    replied
    My take on mushrooms is this:

    1. Mushrooms are already different from potions in minor ways. First, in recent version of Z, and in my version, you find mushrooms in small stacks (2-6 or so), whereas you only find one of each potion at a time. Second, they are food and potions aren't. Third, Z has object theming, which means some monsters are going to be more likely to drop "tools" i.e. food, light, diggers ... without good mushrooms, those treasures could kind of suck.

    So, I don't mind some mushrooms duplicating potions. A mushroom of cure serious wounds is not a good cure, but it's better than a mushroom that does nothing but feed you. Also, mushrooms tend to duplicate crappy potions, which is another problem.

    That said, mushrooms need more unique abilities that potions don't have. I like the random powerful mushroom idea, and I have some others up my sleeves that will be interesting, but I'll let them be a surprise.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jude
    replied
    Originally posted by Donald Jonker



    If you must have mushrooms, make 1 variety with a randomized, unidentifiable, game-changing effect each time you try one (permanently boost/reduce a stat, create/remove mutations, etc.).

    --J
    I like the sound of this too

    Basically I like any idea that involves making mushrooms not the same as potions, however simple or complicated

    also i forgot to mention i too hate the lava, rubble, water, etc levels
    Yes these levels have to go

    I'm playing 2.4.something and there's a few annoying level types but it's NOTHING compared to the awful ones in the newer releases.

    Leave a comment:


  • nobody
    replied
    also i forgot to mention i too hate the lava, rubble, water, etc levels

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by takkaria
    Anyway, I certainly feel that removing mushrooms is a big anti-flavour move, and would advise other variant maintainers to not remove them.
    Can't stand the things myself I took them out of Iron (and Quick? can't remember).

    But if you have a plan for making them better in V then that's good.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nick
    replied
    Originally posted by takkaria
    Anyway, I certainly feel that removing mushrooms is a big anti-flavour move, and would advise other variant maintainers to not remove them.
    ... like you have any power over us, mortal. Especially Un, where the whole game is based on mushrooms for the first few levels (well, kind of).

    EDIT: Starting to rethink the wisdom of posting pre-caffeine...
    Last edited by Nick; July 8, 2008, 22:38.

    Leave a comment:


  • takkaria
    replied
    Originally posted by Donald Jonker
    In my humble opinion, mushrooms ought to be scrapped entirely. As I see it, all the mushroom reform opinions fall into two categories:

    1. Mushrooms should behave like potions, but sometimes with different effects.
    2. Mushrooms should have unique uses/bizarre qualities.
    I considered what you said about removing mushrooms and reducing them down to potions for V, but I figure that there is value in keeping them. (Hairy molds from pre-2.7.x versions of Angband have already been removed, and they merely duplicated mushroom effects.)

    I went with the second, but without any of the NetHackish interactions you deride (and rightfully so). They just have effects which nothing else has, mostly very mixed effects. It might turn out that people never use them, but I hope that they do. If they don't, maybe I'll remove them and make a selection of the potions mushrooms or something like that, instead.

    Anyway, I certainly feel that removing mushrooms is a big anti-flavour move, and would advise other variant maintainers to not remove them.

    Leave a comment:


  • nobody
    replied
    i totally agree that some of the proposed changes for mushrooms would make the game too nethackish, and thats bad.
    i love zangband, and i love the crazy wilderness in 2.6-2.7 and am excited to see the possibility of someone working on it again. any chance in heck of getting it up to a current angband codebase? i imagine thst would be alotta work

    Leave a comment:


  • Donald Jonker
    replied
    Originally posted by Jude
    I like the sounds of your plans.

    I also like that guy's idea about mushrooms...something really needs to be done about mushrooms.

    Also, how about adding some new interesting mutations?
    In my humble opinion, mushrooms ought to be scrapped entirely. As I see it, all the mushroom reform opinions fall into two categories:

    1. Mushrooms should behave like potions, but sometimes with different effects.
    2. Mushrooms should have unique uses/bizarre qualities.

    In the first case, you might as well just make another flavor of potion. Shift all instances of mushrooms of restoring to potions of restoring. Moreover, there is absolutely no need whatsoever for both a mushroom AND a potion of CSW/cure poison/etc. I would much rather run across the potion versions, so it won't take up another inventory spot. The bonus to game flavor isn't big enough to justify having both.

    In the second case, as in the alchemy suggestion above, I think you run the risk of making the game too Nethackish. I'd rather not have to remember a slew of special rules governing the outcomes of various combinations of mushroom/potion flavors. *bands are games of strategy and tactics, not games of checking a spoiler every five minutes to discover another hundred unnecessary interactions.

    If you must have mushrooms, make 1 variety with a randomized, unidentifiable, game-changing effect each time you try one (permanently boost/reduce a stat, create/remove mutations, etc.).

    --J
    Last edited by Donald Jonker; July 8, 2008, 19:12.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jude
    replied
    I like the sounds of your plans.

    I also like that guy's idea about mushrooms...something really needs to be done about mushrooms.

    Also, how about adding some new interesting mutations?

    Leave a comment:


  • Arendil
    replied
    Originally posted by Mangojuice
    I also like the random wilderness; my beef with recent version was that *themed* dungeon-diving can get a little repetitive (how many Bloodletters of Khorne must one kill?)
    A simple remedy would be plenty of short dungeons. One won't get bored if themed dungeons were about 10 levels long...or maximum 20. Second idea is to have many different "themes", so many, that only some of them can appear in any given game, and most likely, each one only once.

    Originally posted by Mangojuice
    My version will have farms, inns on the roads between towns, random quests of many different types, and level-type "feelings" in the Wilderness, so you don't wander into a really hard area without warning.
    Sounds cool. Illusion of real world, total freedom of movement, a lot of randomness and many different types of quests and dungeons, plus some fixed content like special levels here and there, is all I ask from a roguelike.

    So, good luck. I appreciate your effort, and hope you can manage to finish your plans.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕