Improving Z+Angband

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    Are you serious? The no-brainer comment seemed real, but this seems like a joke. By definition, nobody likes grinding. People like levelling, and when you are new to a game, or the game is very good (think Diablo II) the experience of levelling remains interesting for a very long time before it becomes grinding.

    The best angband example is probably worm farming. When you've never done it before, it's quite fun for a little while. Very soon it's not, and you stop. If something about the game's design meant you *had* to do it, that would be ... awful.
    Yes I am absolutely serious.

    > By definition, nobody likes grinding

    I don't think 'like' is quite the right word for the benefit or satisfaction that one gets from the grinding experience. 'Has fun' would also be the wrong word. And yet people do it.

    > The best angband example is probably worm farming. .... If something about the game's design meant you *had* to do it, that would be ... awful

    True. But if a change to the game design meant you could no longer do it, that would suck.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Magnate
    Unfortunately we are using different terminology. My definition of "no-brainer" is a decision that a poor player cannot get wrong. Wearing Thorin is currently a no-brainer, because it has no competition. (You might wear Anarion to melee Morgoth, but that is an extreme edge case which does not apply to poor players.)
    Ha! I hoped you'd say that.

    If a player could readily find both Thorin and an equally good alternative, then yes, that would lead to a challenging decision - wield Thorin or wield the alternative.

    The status quo, however, is better because it leads to several points of challenge:
    (a) somehow obtain Thorin AND
    (b) realise that it is the best alternative AND
    (c) adjust kit to deal with having it AND
    (d) adjust playstyle in response to your new capabilities, OR
    (e) somehow do without Thorin (as a diver often has to do).

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    And then, why would you try to remove opportunities to grind from Angband?

    Many (most?) Angband players like a bit of grinding now and then.

    The ones that don't, find ways not to do it.

    A.
    Are you serious? The no-brainer comment seemed real, but this seems like a joke. By definition, nobody likes grinding. People like levelling, and when you are new to a game, or the game is very good (think Diablo II) the experience of levelling remains interesting for a very long time before it becomes grinding.

    The best angband example is probably worm farming. When you've never done it before, it's quite fun for a little while. Very soon it's not, and you stop. If something about the game's design meant you *had* to do it, that would be ... awful.

    Leave a comment:


  • Magnate
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    For instance, I am very skeptical of any attempt to remove "no-brainer" decisions from Angband.

    No-brainer decisions are what Angband is all about. Specifically, what separates a competent player from a poor player is the ability to consistently make no-brainer decisions correctly.
    Unfortunately we are using different terminology. My definition of "no-brainer" is a decision that a poor player cannot get wrong. Wearing Thorin is currently a no-brainer, because it has no competition. (You might wear Anarion to melee Morgoth, but that is an extreme edge case which does not apply to poor players.)

    Leave a comment:


  • LostTemplar
    replied
    Maybe I missed some options, but running continues even if corridor changes direction, I dont like this behavior, I want to stop and think before every corner and sometimes more often, actually allmost every turn.
    computer's accuracy in noticing things is better than yours
    this statement seems wrong to me, computer ignore many important things (e.g. I probably want to detect or heal or recharge immediately once I have mana for it, or want to go back/dig/destruct/teleport if corridor bends into wrong direction). It is just personal preference to use or not running/autoexplore.

    Leave a comment:


  • zaimoni
    replied
    Originally posted by LostTemplar
    Not detecting in time can kill.
    So, set a count limit on running when detection is available. [This still gets the main benefit of running, which is that the computer's accuracy in noticing things is better than yours.]

    Crawl very intentionally doesn't have adequate detection methods by Angband standards, so this objection doesn't apply to autoexplore there. [They never were Angband-adequate to begin with, but starting with 0.8.0 there are no item sources to speak of; beyond the ranged searching for traps, other long-range detection is controlled by a god choice. "How many cursed items do you want to wear today"?]

    Basically, from Angband-side Crawl autoexplore looks like an APW borg that automatically disengages whenever there's something to attack or damage has been taken.

    Leave a comment:


  • LostTemplar
    replied
    Not detecting in time can kill.

    Leave a comment:


  • zaimoni
    replied
    Originally posted by LostTemplar
    Running in angband can kill too,
    Since the removal of the cut-corners option, running in Angband does not kill @ in ways that are avoidable with manual play. The instant there is a meaningful choice, it stops.

    Crawl's autoexplore will make meaningful choices of what move to make, even going so far as grabbing items for you, until either the whole level is explored or a monster is sighted. The problem is that it likes to move @ in ways that either kill @ before he can react, or cut off escape options so that the mistake that kills @ ~200 moves later has already been committed.

    Leave a comment:


  • zaimoni
    replied
    Originally posted by Bostock
    Example, please?
    Mountain Dwarf Fighter on a level that can generate Ogres. Auto-explore, get interrupted when pathfinder avoidably moves next to an unexplored square. Ogre in square. Ogre gets free attack. Die. (This does seem to be much rarer in 0.7.x, which has my proposed partial pathfinder algorithm fix specifically for preventing this.)

    Alternately, foolishly explore in such a way that three orc priests rather than one are sighted at once: smite, smite, smite, splat.

    Ignoring one-move causes of death that are truly unforeseeable like a unique with a wand of disintegration who zaps the wand on first possible move (which is less than 0.1% of my games), autoexplore fatalities are invariably bad movement doctrine fatalities. Either directly (like the above), or indirectly (by cutting off your own escape routes for you).

    I did propose a partial algorithm fix for instant death by moving adjacent to an unviewable square on RGRD, and from what I can tell that has made it into SS Crawl 0.7.x series. It took several tries to explain because the calculations involved in correcting the pathfinder, were trivial.

    Leave a comment:


  • LostTemplar
    replied
    Running in angband can kill too, more likely then crawl autoexplore, but many players use running. This is a common choice between easy play and safe play, same as diving vs farming.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bostock
    replied
    Originally posted by zaimoni
    Auto-explore is the one major misfeature that Crawl has; it positively doesn't belong in Crawl. On any level where @ isn't overwhelmingly overpowered, autoexplore has a non-zero plausibility of instant-killing @ in one keystroke.
    Example, please?

    I've played a *lot* of Crawl and this has never, never, happened, be I overpowered or (vastly more typically) evenly- or underpowered.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    For instance, I am very skeptical of any attempt to remove "no-brainer" decisions from Angband.
    And then, why would you try to remove opportunities to grind from Angband?

    Many (most?) Angband players like a bit of grinding now and then.

    The ones that don't, find ways not to do it.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • LostTemplar
    replied
    Angband no-brainer combat decisions actually may become interesting with increasing of game difficulty or getting bad luck e.g. if in ironman game you have very limited supply of fail safe escapes or good healing, it may be worth taking some risk instead of wasting them at first sign of danger.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antoine
    replied
    Originally posted by Antoine
    I think *band developers should consider the DCSS Philosophy statement, but not necessarily adapt it. Angband is not Crawl and attempts to use a Crawl approach can lead you astray.
    For instance, I am very skeptical of any attempt to remove "no-brainer" decisions from Angband.

    No-brainer decisions are what Angband is all about. Specifically, what separates a competent player from a poor player is the ability to consistently make no-brainer decisions correctly.

    The poor player's weakness is that, when he's been playing for 4 hours and it's 2 a.m., he thinks 'I'm bound to kill that mob in one more round of attacks - it's only got two stars yet right?'. Even though the no-brainer decision is to take a no-fail escape option.

    A.

    Leave a comment:


  • zaimoni
    replied
    Originally posted by Mangojuice
    But what I really wanted to talk about was the idea of having non-random levels. So I like it, from the point of view of the world being totally consistent. But it's daunting. It's bad enough keeping track of monsters on the current level - how do we keep track of monsters on all other levels that have ever been visited (and walls, traps, objects, doors, etc., too) without a complete explosion in memory? Also, how do we deal with the stairs problem? Right now, stairs allow you to scum for low-hanging fruit. With fixed levels, stairs would give you an absolutely safe escape. Should monsters be able to chase you up or down stairs? I'm worried about messing with the game balance, but it's interesting to think about.
    I've done some prototyping on this for Zaiband. The savefile code needs drastic restructuring to enable this; the player and dungeon save data are critically entangled in V3.0.6, and I don't see any relevant changes that would make things easier in recent V.

    As for the stairs problem: it's a tradeoff. The safe escape also severely impairs stair-scumming (you actually have to make it to a different staircase). Hengband and its descendants have weak level persistence; you need to either Word of Recall or use a different staircase up/down than the the up/down staircase you arrived at to lose the level persistence.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
😀
😂
🥰
😘
🤢
😎
😞
😡
👍
👎
☕